Finding great tacos can change a meal, and Fairport, NY offers a few spots that shine. I discovered bold flavors and fresh ingredients at small, quirky eateries in the area. Each establishment has its own take on the classic taco, making my search both delicious and memorable.

I have sampled tacos in many places, and Fairport stands out for its variety and local charm. This guide covers the spots that promise an enjoyable culinary experience. Read on to see which eateries have earned their reputation and why they deserve a spot on your list.
1. Donnelly’s Public House
Donnelly’s Public House brings a modern twist to Fairport’s dining scene at 1 Water St. I found its warm, relaxed vibe refreshing and inviting.
On one visit, I sampled their inventive tacos. The vegetarian taco stood out with fresh ingredients and bold seasoning, perfectly mirroring the restaurant’s creative spirit.
Ideal for lunch, dinner, or a late-night snack, Donnelly’s offers both table service and takeout. Their tacos capture the essence of Fairport, setting a high standard for local cuisine.
2. Lulu Taqueria and Bar
Lulu Taqueria and Bar, nestled at 6 N Main St, offers an authentic taste of Mexico in Fairport. The lively atmosphere instantly drew me in, sparking excitement for what was to come.
What sets Lulu apart is its commitment to fresh ingredients and vibrant flavors. On my last visit, I indulged in their carne asada tacos, which featured perfectly seasoned meat wrapped in warm tortillas—each bite was a delight.
With a menu available for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, Lulu caters to every craving. Don’t miss their house-made salsa and guacamole, which perfectly complement their tacos. Lulu Taqueria embodies a spirited dining experience that keeps locals coming back for more.
3. Taco Bell
Taco Bell at 2157 Fairport Nine Mile Point Rd offers familiar flavors with modern convenience. I was impressed by its clean, efficient setting, perfect for a quick bite any time of day.
My visit here reminded me why this fast-food chain remains a local favorite; the balance of bold seasoning and consistent quality never disappoints. The classic crunchy taco stands out with its satisfying crunch and zesty taste.
For something extra, try the Crunchwrap Supreme. It captures Taco Bell’s playful twist on traditional tacos while delivering hearty satisfaction. This spot is a reliable go-to for flavorful tacos in Fairport.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: Where can I find the best tacos in Fairport, NY?
A1: You can explore several great spots. Donnelly’s Public House offers inventive tacos with a local twist. Lulu Taqueria and Bar serves authentic, flavorful options, and Taco Bell provides a familiar fast-food fix.
Q2: Are there vegetarian taco options in Fairport?
A2: Yes, many venues cater to vegetarian preferences. Donnelly’s and Lulu Taqueria both provide creative vegetarian taco recipes featuring fresh, local ingredients.
Q3: Do these taco places offer takeout or delivery?
A3: Several spots, such as Taco Bell and Donnelly’s, offer takeout. Online ordering and delivery options are available at selected locations as well.
Q4: Which establishment is best for a quick taco bite?
A4: Taco Bell is a reliable option for a speedy, satisfying taco experience, ideal for a quick meal any time of day.
Q5: Can I get tacos for different mealtimes?
A5: Absolutely. Spots like Lulu Taqueria serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, ensuring you can enjoy tacos throughout the day.