Finding great tacos is a bit like hunting for buried treasure. Geneva, NY, may be small, but the taco scene here punches way above its weight. My first trip to Geneva set the bar high: I found myself biting into a warm tortilla at a busy spot near Seneca Lake. The flavors were simple, not drowned in sauce but rich with that unmistakable balance of spice and freshness. I realized there’s an art to a taco done well, and Geneva continues to impress even the most seasoned taco chasers.
This list brings together both hidden gems and popular favorites where genuine flavors take center stage. Expect to discover places that cook up tacos with character—from beloved local diners to spots where salsa recipes stretch back generations. Whether you love yours with crunchy slaw, tender beef, or fresh pico de gallo, you’ll find options to keep your taste buds busy. Prepare to explore the best Geneva has to offer, one tortilla at a time.
Where to find the best tacos in Geneva, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Geneva, NY:
- The Rusty Pig
- Eddie O’Briens Grille & Bar
- Char Burrito Bar
- Taqueria Los Amigos
- Taco Bell / KFC
- La Fiesta Brava Mexican Restaurant
- Casa Mezcal
- Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar
- El Bajio
- Chipotle Mexican Grill
1. The Rusty Pig
The Rusty Pig delivers tacos with a smoky twist that sets them apart on Geneva’s taco trail. Walking through the door, the aroma of slow-cooked meats is impossible to miss. The vibe strikes an easy balance—laid-back but always lively, especially when the street outside is buzzing.
What separates The Rusty Pig is their approach to ingredients and flavor. Here, meats spend hours in a smoker, absorbing layers of taste that make every bite memorable. Their taco fillings have depth—a subtle char mixed with tender sweetness.
The pulled chicken tacos are my staple order. Served with fresh slaw and house-made sauce, they’re a satisfying combination of tang, crunch, and smoke. It’s the kind of plate that keeps you coming back, long after the last taco is gone.
2. Eddie O’Briens Grille & Bar
Eddie O’Briens Grille & Bar does tacos with a pub-inspired twist that’s hard to resist. The atmosphere is relaxed enough for a casual lunch but lively if you show up for dinner with friends. There’s always energy in the room, whether you’re catching a game or just catching up.
Their taco menu gets creative with fresh, high-quality ingredients. A standout for me is the grilled shrimp tacos. Light, a little zesty, and tucked into warm tortillas, they’re a fresh option that delivers on taste.
Vegetarian? You’re not left out here. The kitchen puts just as much effort into veggie tacos, layering textures and flavors so every bite counts. This is the spot for those looking for something outside the ordinary taco lineup.
3. Char Burrito Bar
Char Burrito Bar makes its mark in Geneva with a taco lineup that feels bright, customizable, and fun. My first stop here came after a long morning walk along Castle Street. I remember how the staff made each order from scratch, letting you build your own masterpiece.
The options here suit every mood and diet. Vegan, vegetarian, or gluten-free? They’ll have you covered, no questions asked. The ability to pick your base, toppings, and fresh salsas makes each taco feel like a one-of-a-kind creation.
Don’t skip their grilled veggie tacos or the classic black bean filling. Paired with their tangy house salsa, you get a bite that’s both hearty and bright—a reflection of Char’s playful, modern approach to tacos.
4. Taqueria Los Amigos
Taqueria Los Amigos feels like a slice of Mexico nestled in downtown Geneva. The space hums with the aroma of sizzling tortillas and slow-stewed fillings, echoing the comfort of a home kitchen in Guanajuato. My first visit brought a wave of nostalgia—the flavors here seem to come straight from family recipes passed down through generations.
Authenticity is the backbone at Los Amigos. Every taco is built on fresh, soft corn tortillas, matched with well-seasoned fillings. The care put into each order is easy to taste.
Try their carne asada or their veggie tacos. Both deliver simple, focused flavors with bright salsas and crisp toppings. If you’re searching for traditional Mexican tacos in Geneva, Los Amigos is where you’ll want to start.
5. Taco Bell / KFC
Taco Bell / KFC brings a quick, familiar option for taco enthusiasts in Geneva. Sometimes you need something fast and reliable—this spot delivers just that. The menu keeps things straightforward, with recognizable tacos ready in minutes.
Taco Bell’s style is all about creative combinations and that signature crunch. On busy days, I’ve swung by for a quick meal, enjoying the convenience of a drive-thru and the consistency of their flavors.
Go for the Soft Taco or Crunchy Taco Supreme. Both offer a satisfying bite with classic lettuce, cheese, and seasoned beef or beans. If you want your tacos with extra texture and a bit of nostalgia, Taco Bell stands ready to serve.
6. La Fiesta Brava Mexican Restaurant
La Fiesta Brava Mexican Restaurant, just a short drive from Geneva in Waterloo, brings a warm, family-style approach to classic Mexican fare. Stepping inside, the colorful décor and lively conversations set the mood for a relaxed meal. I remember sitting by the window, watching Main Street while savoring flavors that felt both robust and comforting.
This spot stands out for its generous portions and friendly service. The staff knows their regulars and makes newcomers feel right at home.
Order the chicken or veggie tacos, served with fluffy rice and slow-cooked beans. Each taco is built on a soft shell, filled with fresh toppings and a kick of house-made salsa. If you want a taste of old-school, hearty Mexican cooking, Fiesta Brava has you covered.
7. Casa Mezcal
Casa Mezcal, tucked away in Penn Yan, brings modern flair to traditional Mexican dishes. Walking into the dining room, I noticed the subtle blend of old and new—rustic accents paired with a lively, contemporary vibe. The service always feels genuine here, adding a personal touch to every visit.
Casa Mezcal sets itself apart through thoughtful presentation and layered flavors. The kitchen takes pride in every plate, balancing freshness with the deep, smoky notes that define their style.
The grilled fish tacos are a standout. They arrive with crisp slaw and bright salsa, capturing the essence of coastal Mexico in every bite. For those craving freshness and a hint of adventure, Casa Mezcal is an easy recommendation.
8. Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar
Laguna Grande Restaurante Mexicano & Bar sits across from Canandaigua Lake, adding a splash of scenery to every meal. I first stopped in after a lakeside walk, and the generous patio seating made it easy to relax and unwind.
The kitchen here focuses on clean flavors and simple, colorful presentations. It’s a great spot for big groups or a casual dinner with friends, with a menu that balances classics and seasonal specials.
Chicken or fish tacos are the go-to. Each order comes with fresh toppings and a dollop of zesty house salsa that brightens everything up. Laguna Grande’s tacos reflect a blend of comfort and freshness, perfect after a day by the water.
9. El Bajio
El Bajio brings authentic Mexican flavors right to the heart of Seneca Falls. The aroma of roasting spices and homemade tortillas greeted me before I even walked through the door. It’s the type of place that feels welcoming whether you’re dining in or picking up an order to go.
What sets El Bajio apart is their attention to tradition and detail. Flavors blend seamlessly, and everything is made with a sense of pride that shines through in every taco.
Try the chicken or sautéed veggie tacos. They’re served on soft, warm tortillas, piled high with crisp toppings and a kick of house-made salsa. El Bajio is a perfect spot for anyone craving a true taste of Mexico in the Finger Lakes region.
10. Chipotle Mexican Grill
Chipotle Mexican Grill in Canandaigua offers a familiar, customizable take on Mexican classics. There’s a sense of efficiency here—your order moves from fresh prep to plate in minutes without sacrificing quality. For a quick lunch or easy dinner, Chipotle has become my dependable go-to when I’m nearby.
The build-your-own setup means you’re always in control of what goes into your meal. Fresh ingredients stand out, especially the pico de gallo and cilantro-lime rice, which add brightness to every bite.
The chicken and veggie tacos are always solid picks. Soft tortillas cradle seasoned fillings, and there’s plenty of topping options to match your cravings. Chipotle’s approach keeps things straightforward and satisfying, perfect for a fast, flavorful meal.
More Things to Try in Geneva, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for tacos in Geneva, NY?
Geneva has a range of top taco spots, including The Rusty Pig, Taqueria Los Amigos, Char Burrito Bar, and Eddie O’Briens Grille & Bar. Several other restaurants, including La Fiesta Brava and Casa Mezcal, are also worth a drive from Geneva for taco lovers.
Are there vegetarian or vegan taco options in Geneva?
Yes, you’ll find vegetarian and even vegan tacos at places like Char Burrito Bar and Chipotle Mexican Grill. Many restaurants, including Eddie O’Briens and El Bajio, also offer fresh veggie taco choices.
Do any places serve authentic Mexican tacos near Geneva?
Taqueria Los Amigos and El Bajio are known for their authentic Mexican tacos, often made using family recipes and traditional cooking methods.
Can I find gluten-free tacos in Geneva?
Absolutely. Char Burrito Bar and Chipotle Mexican Grill make it easy to build gluten-free tacos, and many local spots offer corn tortillas as a substitute upon request.
Which taco spot is best for a quick bite?
Taco Bell offers classic fast-food tacos if you’re in a hurry, while Chipotle is another solid choice for a fast, fresh meal on the go.
Is there a place to get tacos late at night in Geneva?
Eddie O’Briens Grille & Bar is open late, making it a popular spot for a late-night taco fix after a long day or evening out.
