You could comb through cities, scroll endless menus, and still miss that golden taco hiding in plain sight. South Hill, NY, for all its unassuming charm, knows how to put magic in a tortilla. Finding the best tacos isn’t just about the meat or the salsa, it’s about that lightning-bolt moment when flavor and texture line up and surprise you.
There’s a lot of ground to cover and many plates to sample—trust me, I’ve done the hard work, shell by shell, one ordered extra guac at a time. From street-style to inventive modern twists, the local lineup never disappoints. This guide brings you right up to the counter at the finest taco spots in South Hill: no guesswork, no disappointments, just pure delight waiting to happen.
Where to find the best tacos in South Hill, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in South Hill, NY:
- El Campeon De Los Pollos
- Alberto’s
- Don Pollo
- Don Tequila Urban Cantina
- Homemade Taqueria Jamaica
- Mas Tortilla Ny
- Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills
- Restaurant Peruvian El Chalaco
- Mundo’s Lounge
- Doayayo Reastaurant
1. El Campeon De Los Pollos
Step into El Campeon De Los Pollos and you’ll smell what sets this place apart before anything else—a grill going strong and every taco coming out piping hot. This spot isn’t just another stop; it feels like someone handed the family recipes straight to the cooks. I remember my last visit, squeezing a wedge of lime over a double-stacked chicken taco and catching a smoky aroma unlike any other.
Their chicken tacos steal the show, with tender, marinated bites wrapped in warm corn tortillas. You’ll taste a balance of spice and char that only comes from proper grilling. If you like to mix things up, try the steak version too. No matter your order, expect flavor that feels personal—every single time.
2. Alberto’s
(718) 268-7860Call
Alberto’s blends casual comfort with serious flavor. This Forest Hills favorite tucks classic Mexican favorites behind an unassuming storefront. I came in expecting quick, no-frills food but left surprised by a plate that showed real care for tradition and freshness.
Their beef tacos come with a satisfying, home-cooked edge—think juicy, well-seasoned meat and tortillas that hold their own. If you want a little extra kick, try the grilled fish taco, which balances flaky texture with bright, zesty toppings. The menu makes it easy for anyone to find a favorite, whether it’s your first taco or your fiftieth.
At Alberto’s, you can taste the difference in every bite. They keep the atmosphere friendly, which makes every visit feel like stopping in at an old friend’s kitchen.
3. Don Pollo
Don Pollo is where you go when you want both comfort and character in your tacos. This Ozone Park staple knows rotisserie chicken, and the way they fold it into their tacos is pure genius. During my last visit, I bit into a chicken taco that felt like the work of someone who takes seasoning seriously.
The signature rotisserie chicken taco is the highlight—moist, richly spiced chicken, a hint of smoky char, and a fresh tortilla that brings it all together. If you’re in the mood to branch out, their beef tacos are equally worth a shot, bringing a savory edge with every bite.
For a taco that’s both deeply satisfying and uniquely Peruvian, Don Pollo’s blend of flavors keeps the regulars coming back. Don’t leave without trying their house hot sauce for the perfect finish.
4. Don Tequila Urban Cantina
Don Tequila Urban Cantina manages to feel lively and laid-back at the same time, serving up tacos that taste as vibrant as the decor. My first time there, I noticed the genuine care put into each plate—the flavors spoke for themselves.
The grilled shrimp taco is a house favorite. It’s loaded with sweet, juicy shrimp and topped with crisp veggies and a splash of fresh lime. For something classic, the chicken or steak tacos show off their commitment to high-quality, local ingredients.
This cantina captures what great tacos are all about: bold flavors made from scratch, served fast without cutting corners. For adventurous taco seekers, this is a can’t-miss stop in South Hill.
5. Homemade Taqueria Jamaica
Homemade Taqueria Jamaica brings the comfort of a home-cooked meal to the heart of South Hill. Walk in, and you’re met with the inviting scent of fresh tortillas and the buzz of regulars who know a good taco when they taste one. My last visit left me hooked on their signature carnitas taco—juicy, slow-cooked pork with a citrus kick that melts right into the warm corn tortilla.
Freshness is the real star here. Every taco hits the table just off the grill, loaded with lively toppings that snap with flavor. The fish taco is another standout, perfectly balanced and light but never boring.
This is a place where tacos feel both familiar and elevated, rooted in tradition and made for sharing with friends and family. Don’t skip their homemade salsas—they complete the experience.
6. Mas Tortilla Ny
Mas Tortilla Ny is the kind of place you discover once, and then keep coming back to satisfy taco cravings. The open kitchen buzzes with energy, and watching tortillas puff up on the grill is almost as good as that first bite. Last time I stopped in, I ordered their grilled chicken tacos—moist, flavorful, and generously topped with crisp veggies and tangy salsa.
The tortillas are made fresh in-house, giving every taco a soft, authentic texture you just don’t find everywhere. Their veggie tacos are also a smart pick: hearty, colorful, and unmistakably fresh.
This spot brings a mix of casual atmosphere and serious attention to quality. For a laid-back taco night with friends, Mas Tortilla Ny is one local gem that never disappoints.
7. Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills
Homemade Taqueria Forest Hills has the kind of menu that feels like a handwritten invitation to enjoy true Mexican comfort food. The first time I stopped by, I was caught off guard by the burst of flavor in their classic carnitas taco, each bite juicy and fragrant on a pillow-soft corn tortilla.
Everything is made with freshness in mind, and you can taste it from the guacamole to the salsa. The fish tacos impress as well—breaded light, topped with crisp slaw, and finished with a bright squeeze of lime. Every taco here feels well-considered, highlighting each ingredient without hiding behind heavy sauces or shortcuts.
This place brings a warm, communal energy. Perfect for family gatherings or solo cravings alike, it keeps regulars loyal for a reason.
8. Restaurant Peruvian El Chalaco
Restaurant Peruvian El Chalaco blends Peruvian warmth with bold Mexican flavors in a cozy, family-style setting. This spot stands out for its friendly service and the lively, authentic approach to every plate. On my last trip, I tried their grilled chicken taco—delicate char, fresh cilantro, and a taste that lingered long after.
The tacos here showcase a melding of Peruvian flair and classic Mexican technique. Their fish tacos, packed with mild, flaky fish and bright, fresh toppings, are a must for anyone craving something a little different from the norm.
This is a perfect option if you want adventurous flavors that still feel familiar and comforting. Share a few plates, relax, and let the kitchen surprise you.
9. Mundo’s Lounge
Mundo’s Lounge is more than its name suggests. The atmosphere is effortless—think local hangout with colorful plates and an easy rhythm. I wandered in one weeknight and found myself eyeing the tacos before I even saw a menu, simply because of the aroma drifting from the kitchen.
The chicken tacos here are generous and packed with well-marinated meat, complemented with fresh toppings and just the right amount of sauce. For something with a twist, the veggie taco stands out—crisp, grilled vegetables, lively seasonings, and that undeniable just-off-the-grill flavor.
If you’re after a spot where tacos are both fun and filling, Mundo’s Lounge delivers. Order a couple, settle in, and enjoy the laid-back vibe that’s hard to leave behind.
10. Doayayo Reastaurant
(718) 322-3920Call
Doayayo Restaurant is easy to stroll past, but step inside and you’ll understand its devoted following. The space is intimate yet lively, buzzing with families and friends sharing plates. My first visit, I was swayed by the soft corn tortillas and the aroma of spices filling the air.
The beef taco is their signature here—tender, well-seasoned meat wrapped in a fresh tortilla that holds everything together just right. For a lighter bite, try the chicken tacos, which are juicy and topped with fresh, vibrant veggies.
This is a spot where every taco feels made to order, with classic flavors that never get old. Expect a genuine, no-nonsense experience that’s all about what’s on your plate.
More Things to Try in South Hill, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of tacos are most popular in South Hill, NY?
The most popular options tend to be grilled chicken, beef, carnitas (slow-cooked pork), and vegetarian tacos. Local taquerias offer specialty fish and shrimp tacos as well, giving you classic and creative choices.
Are there vegetarian taco options available?
Absolutely. Many South Hill taco spots serve grilled vegetable, bean, or cheese tacos. Veggie tacos are highlighted at places like Mas Tortilla Ny and Mundo’s Lounge for their fresh taste and variety.
Do any restaurants offer homemade tortillas?
Yes. Spots like Homemade Taqueria and Mas Tortilla Ny pride themselves on fresh, in-house tortillas, which make a noticeable difference in flavor and texture.
Can I find authentic Mexican street tacos in South Hill?
You can. Several local restaurants focus on street-style tacos, known for simple fillings, fresh onions, cilantro, and just a squeeze of lime on warm corn tortillas.
Are the taco restaurants family friendly?
Most places on this list welcome families and provide a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. Homemade Taqueria and El Campeon De Los Pollos, in particular, are perfect for groups and all ages.
