Tracking down the best tacos in Nutley, NJ is not a sprint. It’s a slow, flavorful stroll down Franklin Avenue, around tucked-away corners, and sometimes a side step into a tiny taqueria you’ve passed a hundred times. The range in town surprises me every time I dig in—some places serve up classic street-style tacos, while others give their own twist that keeps locals buzzing. One night, I tried a spot hidden off the main strip and ended up chatting with the owner about his secret blend of spices—which led to the juiciest chicken taco I’d tasted in months. Nutley has that way of blending the unexpected with the familiar, bite after bite.
Choosing the right tacos comes down to details: warm tortillas with enough snap, freshness in every topping, and flavor that lingers just long enough. If you’re scanning for crispy fish, charred beef, or creative veggie fillings, Nutley’s options are too good to breeze past. Whether you’ve just moved here or have always called Nutley home, this guide aims to lead you straight to that next taco spot you’ll want to revisit (and probably tell your friends about). Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best tacos in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Nutley, NJ:
- Alberto’s
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Pancho’s Burritos
- Los Jarros Mexican Grill
- Tacos la gringa 2
- Marlitos Burritos
- Chevys Fresh Mex
- Taco Bell
- Tio Taco + Tequila
- Metropolis Mexican Grill
1. Alberto’s
(973) 751-7519Call
Alberto’s brings a taste of Latin America right to the edge of Nutley. Tucked on Washington Ave, this eatery leans into cozy and casual, but what hooked me was their strong lineup of tacos. There’s plenty to tempt you on the menu, yet I keep circling back to the beef tacos. They don’t skimp on the flavor—each tortilla comes loaded with seasoned, slow-cooked meat and a healthy dose of vibrant salsa.
The tacos here pack a punch without being overdone. The fillings hold up beautifully, and the toppings are always fresh. For a satisfying bite, the chicken tacos are my second pick. They taste homemade, the kind you’d be proud to call lunch or dinner.
What really gives Alberto’s its edge is a menu that goes beyond tacos, yet never lets the basics slide. When you want a reliable taco spot with a Latin twist, this place delivers, bite after bite.
2. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill in Clifton sits just outside Nutley, but the drive is worth it if you crave quick, customizable tacos. The upbeat vibe always makes me linger a little longer than planned—plus, every meal comes with free chips and house-made salsa. Freshness is on full display, right down to the salsa bar and seasonal ingredients.
You build your taco your way here, which makes the experience personal. I go for the grilled chicken tacos with a scoop of black beans and shredded lettuce. The tortillas are warm, never soggy, and every bite feels bright and balanced.
The cool part? Extras like the smoky corn pico let you get a little creative. Moe’s captures that fast-casual feel but reminds you that quality and choice matter. If you want tacos on your terms, this spot nails it every time.
3. Pancho’s Burritos
(973) 667-8226Call
Pancho’s Burritos on Franklin Ave is that no-frills spot locals recommend when you want good Mexican food without drama. It’s compact and friendly, and you’ll always spot regulars grabbing their favorites. I’ve ended up here countless times, chasing a craving for generously filled tacos.
The beef and shrimp tacos are why I keep coming back. The fillings are fresh, the flavors straightforward, and every taco is stacked—no stingy portions here. The tortillas hold up even when you add a splash of their house salsa, which is a solid move if you like a little kick.
This spot stands out because it never overcomplicates the classics. If you want a simple plate of just-right tacos with good value and zero pretense, Pancho’s delivers the goods.
4. Los Jarros Mexican Grill
Los Jarros Mexican Grill sits on Union Ave, drawing you in with its inviting atmosphere and rich aromas. The first time I walked in, I was greeted like a regular even though it was my first visit. Their menu keeps things focused on fresh, bold Mexican flavors that speak for themselves.
The carne asada tacos here are a standout, every bite layered with tender beef, crisp onions, and a fresh sprinkle of cilantro. The tortillas are warm and never overpower the fillings, letting the core flavors shine. I also recommend the grilled veggie tacos, which show off how even the simplest ingredients can impress when handled right.
What sets Los Jarros apart is their consistency. Each visit delivers the same balance of flavor and freshness. If you want tacos that feel like a treat every time, you’ll find them right here.
5. Tacos la gringa 2
Tacos la gringa 2 is a gem that keeps calling me back, especially when I’m after something less ordinary. Tucked along Broad St, this spot blends classic Mexican techniques with their own playful twist. The staff is warm and ready to talk you through the menu if you get stuck, which is easy with so many tempting options.
If you want to try their best, go for the al pastor tacos. They get the marinade just right—smoky, a hint of sweet, and always tender. Another favorite is the grilled fish taco, which offers a lighter, bright bite that still brings plenty of flavor.
Tacos la gringa 2 stands out for creativity and care. Each taco feels like it’s made with real attention, balancing spice, acidity, and fresh toppings in every bite.
6. Marlitos Burritos
(973) 320-2250Call
Marlitos Burritos on Franklin Ave may have “burritos” in its name, but the tacos here are not to be missed. I first wandered in after a friend’s suggestion and left with a new weeknight go-to. The place is casual and inviting, with staff who don’t mind sharing their recommendations.
The grilled steak tacos are the clear frontrunner. Each bite brings a smoky char, tender beef, and a hint of lime that lingers. The toppings stay simple—crisp lettuce, diced tomato, and a touch of their signature sauce. It’s comfort food with extra freshness.
Marlitos stands out for generous portions and fair prices. If you’re in the mood for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with flavor that feels homemade, these tacos get it right every time.
7. Chevys Fresh Mex
Chevys Fresh Mex in Clifton brings you big, lively energy and food that lives up to the name “fresh.” I found myself drawn in by the open kitchen, where you can watch handmade tortillas appear right before your eyes. It’s a great spot for groups, but solo visits feel just as welcoming.
The grilled chicken tacos are my staple pick here. The tortillas are soft and slightly smoky, while the chicken stays juicy and perfectly seasoned. Topped with crunchy lettuce and pico de gallo, they’re balanced and satisfying.
What sets Chevys apart is their commitment to making everything from scratch, daily. For taco lovers who value both tradition and freshness, Chevys blends the two effortlessly, adding an extra layer of flavor you’ll taste in every bite.
8. Taco Bell
Taco Bell on Washington Ave in Belleville is the go-to for a reliable, quick taco fix. Honestly, sometimes you just want tacos without all the fuss, and Taco Bell fills that need perfectly. I’ve swung by more times than I’d admit, especially on late nights or those days when only crunchy tacos will do.
The crunchy taco and soft taco are classic choices here, both offering that familiar combo of seasoned beef or beans, crisp lettuce, and shredded cheese. It’s a satisfying bite that requires no explanation and always hits the spot when speed and value matter most.
Taco Bell stands out for its convenience and menu variety. Options like their vegetarian tacos keep it interesting, whether you’re dining in or grabbing a meal on the go. Perfect for taco cravings on a budget, with a taste you know by heart.
9. Tio Taco + Tequila
Tio Taco + Tequila on Route 3 skips the shortcuts and goes big on vibrant, modern flavors. I wandered in for a casual dinner and ended up making a meal of tacos alone—no regrets. The setting is energetic, with an open kitchen feel and friendly staff ready to customize every plate.
The grilled shrimp tacos won me over first. They’re bright, a little smoky, and finished with a tangy slaw that pulls everything together. If fish is more your thing, the grilled fish tacos bring a perfectly fresh bite with every order.
Tio Taco stands out for its mix of tradition and bold new flavors. Whether you want to try classic fillings or something unexpected, their tacos serve personality and quality in equal measure.
10. Metropolis Mexican Grill
(973) 667-0202Call
Metropolis Mexican Grill on Union Ave combines flavor, value, and a welcoming vibe that makes you want to become a regular. My first visit happened almost by accident, and that spontaneous stop quickly became part of my Taco Tuesday routine. The menu offers a wide mix, but the tacos deserve extra attention.
The chicken tacos here are top-notch—tender, well-seasoned, and finished with fresh pico de gallo. The tortillas hold up, never soggy or dry, which adds to the overall experience. If you like a little heat, their house-made salsa brings just enough spice to keep things interesting.
Consistency and value are Metropolis’s strong suits. For fast, affordable, and always fresh tacos in Nutley, Metropolis manages to stand out in a crowded field.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular taco spots in Nutley, NJ?
Nutley is packed with great options. Locals rave about Pancho’s Burritos, Los Jarros Mexican Grill, and Metropolis Mexican Grill for their fresh ingredients and consistent flavors. For something different, Tio Taco + Tequila offers inventive taco choices just around the corner.
Are there vegetarian taco options in Nutley?
Definitely. Most places, including Chevys Fresh Mex and Taco Bell, offer vegetarian fillings like beans, grilled veggies, and more. Ask for no animal products if you need something strictly plant-based.
Where can I get tacos late at night near Nutley?
Taco Bell is your reliable late-night spot. Some other grills and taquerias keep later hours, especially on weekends, so it’s worth checking local hours online or by phone first.
Which taco places have delivery or takeout?
Nearly every spot now offers takeout, and most partner with delivery apps. Metropolis Mexican Grill, Pancho’s Burritos, and Moe’s Southwest Grill all have fast, easy options for eating at home.
What makes tacos in Nutley unique?
Nutley tacos bring together a mix of traditional and creative flavors. Many spots use homemade salsas and warm tortillas, and some infuse Latin American twists that set them apart from big-city chains.
