Craving the real deal? Taco hunting in Brookville, NY is anything but boring. This small pocket of Long Island isn’t shouting about its taco credentials, but that’s part of the charm. After plenty of taste-testing—think smoky chicken, tender carne asada, and vibrant salsas—I’ve found the local taco scene is quietly thriving. Each spot has its own spin, from family-owned taquerias with recipes passed down through generations, to modern kitchens blending regional flavors.
Whether I’m squeezing fresh lime over my first bite or comparing hidden gems with friends, I keep stumbling onto unexpected favorites. The delight is in the discovery. This guide highlights the taco joints that deserve your attention. It isn’t about hype, it’s about actual flavor. Curious? Let’s dig into the best tacos Brookville has to offer—no search for parking or bland tortillas required.
Where to find the best tacos in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Brookville, NY:
- GUAC Shop Mexican Grill
- Cozymel’s Mexican Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Besito
- Puerto Vallarta
- La Verne
- Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury
- Desi Fire Grill
- Owen’s Tacos Syosset
- QDOBA Mexican Eats
1. GUAC Shop Mexican Grill
GUAC Shop Mexican Grill sits quietly on Jericho Turnpike, yet has a knack for drawing in taco lovers from all over Brookville. The moment you walk in, it’s clear that the vibe is both laid-back and lively—think colorful decor with the aroma of sizzling tortillas pulling you closer to the counter.
The star here is the taco lineup. Their chicken and steak tacos come loaded, generously portioned and always fresh. Every taco is made to order, crafted with well-spiced proteins and toppings that offer both crunch and zest. The guacamole—naturally—is made in-house and never disappoints.
If you’re torn about what to order, go for their grilled chicken taco with pico de gallo. It’s a classic, built with quality ingredients and flavors that feel both simple and satisfying. GUAC Shop’s balance of freshness and taste keeps me coming back.
2. Cozymel’s Mexican Grill
Cozymel’s Mexican Grill in Westbury mixes casual comfort with a festive atmosphere. Plush booths and warm lighting make it an easy pick for both quick lunches and relaxed dinners. The real surprise, though, is how much they care about getting the basics right.
I always linger longest over their taco menu. Each taco comes thoughtfully plated, with fillings that don’t hide behind heavy sauces. The grilled fish tacos win my vote—flaky, fresh, and paired with a cabbage slaw that brings all the flavors to life.
Their vegetarian taco is another standout, loaded with seasoned veggies and black beans. The focus at Cozymel’s is on balanced flavors, with generous helpings that don’t skimp on freshness. Every visit feels like a small escape from a rushed day.
3. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill in Greenvale feels friendly from the moment you walk in. There’s a fun, upbeat energy that makes solo lunches or group outings equally inviting. Customizing your meal is the secret sauce here.
The taco bar is packed with fresh choices, and every ingredient is prepped throughout the day. At Moe’s, I always go straight for the grilled chicken tacos. The chicken is juicy and seasoned well, paired with vibrant pico de gallo and a kick of their chunky salsa.
Vegetarian options aren’t an afterthought either—their tofu and bean tacos are hearty and not just filler. Top it all off with house-made salsas and a side of free chips, and you’ve got a taco stop that never feels routine.
4. Besito
Besito presents a more refined taco experience in Roslyn, yet never feels stuffy. Step inside and you’re greeted by soft lighting, warm colors, and attentive staff who know the menu inside out. This isn’t your average taqueria; it’s where Mexican flavors meet a bit of elegance.
I’m always impressed by Besito’s taco selection, especially their adobo chicken tacos. They arrive with just the right touch of spice and a squeeze of lime, showcasing fresh ingredients and true attention to detail.
The vegetarian tacos, filled with seasoned vegetables and a tangy salsa, hold their own with layers of flavor. For anyone seeking tacos that feel special, Besito brings a level of care and quality hard to beat.
5. Puerto Vallarta
Puerto Vallarta in Glen Cove makes you feel like you’ve stepped into a family-run spot in coastal Mexico. There’s a relaxed warmth in the air, and the space is always buzzing with regulars. The draw here is authenticity—classic tacos, no overthinking needed.
I usually opt for their shrimp tacos, which stand out for their simple, bold flavors. The shrimp are grilled to order and tucked into soft tortillas with crisp lettuce and a gentle salsa, letting the seafood shine.
The chicken tacos are another solid bet, juicy and generous, with just enough heat but never overwhelming. Puerto Vallarta’s approach is unfussy, relying on quality ingredients and well-tested recipes—all the makings of a real neighborhood find.
6. La Verne
(516) 333-7781Call
La Verne in Westbury keeps it simple and genuine. This is one of those spots where locals know to go when craving classic Mexican comfort. The setting is modest, but the food always feels home-cooked and welcoming.
On my last visit, the fish tacos were a real standout. The fish was flaky, with a house-made sauce that added brightness without overpowering. Every taco is made to order and arrives at the table steaming and full of flavor.
The vegetarian tacos, loaded with seasoned peppers and onions, are just as satisfying. La Verne’s strength is consistency—you know you’ll get tacos that deliver every time, both in freshness and in taste.
7. Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury
(516) 864-0068Call
See Menu
Dirty Taco And Tequila Woodbury knows how to keep things lively. The place is vibrant, always humming with energy, and you get the feeling that every detail matters—from the retro-chic decor to the music selection. The tacos here aren’t afraid to play with bold flavors.
One bite of their Korean-inspired chicken taco and it’s clear they love to take risks that pay off. The combination of tangy sauces and crisp toppings keeps things interesting without going overboard.
The Baja fish taco also shines: crunchy on the outside, tender inside, and topped with fresh slaw for balance. Dirty Taco’s menu feels adventurous, but it’s always anchored by quality and fun, never sacrificing taste for trends.
8. Desi Fire Grill
(516) 681-3111Call
Desi Fire Grill in Hicksville brings a unique twist to the taco scene with its fusion of halal and Indian-inspired flavors. The vibe is casual, but there’s a sense that something a bit different is going on. It’s not every day you see tikka and masala on a taco menu.
Here, I go for the paneer tikka taco every time. It’s creamy, spiced just right, and perfectly tucked into a soft tortilla. The fresh cilantro and cool chutney tie it all together and keep each bite interesting.
The chicken seekh kebab taco is another winner—juicy, loaded with bold spices, and unmistakably original. Desi Fire Grill’s mashup approach works, creating tacos you won’t find anywhere else in Brookville.
9. Owen’s Tacos Syosset
Owen’s Tacos Syosset is a spot that cares about real Mexican flavor and it shows in every detail. The kitchen turns out tacos that are both bold and vibrant, packed with fresh toppings that never feel like an afterthought. There’s a genuine sense of pride behind each dish.
I keep coming back for their grilled chicken and fish tacos. The chicken comes off the grill juicy and flavorful, topped with just the right amount of salsa and lime. The fish tacos here are also worth your attention, lightly battered with a crisp finish and a tangy slaw.
Presentation matters, but at Owen’s, taste is center stage—each taco feels like a celebration of well-balanced, straightforward ingredients.
10. QDOBA Mexican Eats
QDOBA Mexican Eats in Plainview has a modern, upbeat vibe and tacos that never feel rushed or generic. Think fast-casual with a bit more personality, where customization is king. The appeal is the freedom to make your taco exactly as you want it, down to every last topping.
I always order the grilled adobo chicken tacos. The chicken is flame-grilled, juicy, and packed with smoky flavor. You can pile on crisp lettuce, fresh pico, and that bright cilantro-lime rice—it’s all made to order and always fresh.
The fajita veggie taco is another easy favorite, loaded with peppers and onions that bring just the right charred sweetness. QDOBA’s approachable style makes it a favorite for quick taco cravings and bigger gatherings alike.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What kinds of tacos are most popular in Brookville, NY?
Brookville’s taco spots usually offer grilled chicken, steak, fish, and vegetarian tacos. Each restaurant puts its own spin on the classics, so you’ll find options with fresh salsas, tangy slaws, and bold spices.
Are there any halal or vegetarian taco options nearby?
Yes! Spots like Desi Fire Grill serve halal tacos, while many others offer vegetarian choices with ingredients like grilled veggies, black beans, or paneer.
Where can I find authentic Mexican tacos in the area?
Owen’s Tacos Syosset and Puerto Vallarta are known for their authentic approach, focusing on well-seasoned meats and house-made tortillas.
Can I get tacos to-go or for catering?
Most places, including QDOBA and Moe’s Southwest Grill, offer takeout and catering options. You can easily order online or by phone for pickup or delivery.
Which taco spots are family-friendly?
QDOBA Mexican Eats and GUAC Shop Mexican Grill provide relaxed settings with plenty of menu choices for all ages.
