Good tacos are easy to find. Great tacos? That’s an art. Centereach, NY is not just a sleepy Long Island suburb—it’s quietly become a hub for inventive, satisfying, and downright craveable tacos. After too many disappointing tacos elsewhere, I set out to find the kind you remember days later. My hunt led to hidden gems, neighborhood favorites, and the kind of counter spots where locals and newcomers swap tips on the best salsa. Each spot has its unique spin, but all deliver flavor without cutting corners.
When searching for the best tacos in Centereach, I looked for fresh ingredients, bold combinations, and—crucially—kitchens that keep it strictly halal. Expect honest takes, a dash of story, and zero exaggeration. Whether you want a quick bite or a plate to linger over, you’ll find options to fuel every craving. Dive in for a tour that leaves bland tacos far behind.
Where to find the best tacos in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Centereach, NY:
- Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
- Holy Guacamole
- Chimichanga Mexican Grill
- Senor Taco Mexican Grill
- Chili’s Grill & Bar
- Taco Bell
- El Rio Restaurant
- Taquerza Y Restaurant
1. Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill knows that freshness is non-negotiable when it comes to tacos. I remember stepping in after a long workday, instantly pulled toward the aroma of sizzling grilled veggies and warm tortillas. The staff prepare everything to order, so each taco tastes like it was just dreamed up in the kitchen.
Unlike many fast-casual spots, Cabo Fresh refuses to cut corners. They use all-natural ingredients and organic produce whenever possible. Their salsas and guacamole come without preservatives—just lively flavors and quality you can taste.
If you’re here for tacos, try the Grilled Chicken or Veggie Tacos, both wrapped in soft corn tortillas and topped with crunchy cabbage, pico, and a drizzle of their signature salsa. Each bite captures Cabo’s commitment to clean, bold flavors that don’t need to shout to be memorable.
2. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill is the kind of spot where the mood is casual and the options are plentiful. On my last visit, I was greeted by the sound of tortillas warming and a team ready to build your meal any way you like. The best part? Free chips and ultra-fresh salsa with every order—a welcome treat while you wait for your main dish.
The taco lineup at Moe’s lets you play with bold fillings and zesty toppings. Try their Grilled Chicken or Grilled Veggie Tacos, layered with black beans, pico de gallo, and shredded lettuce for that classic Southwest crunch. Each bite proves that made-to-order really makes a difference.
Moe’s delivers comfort food you can customize, all in a lively space right in the heart of Centereach Mall. If you like mixing things up, this is your place.
3. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Taco El Primo Restaurant feels like a true neighborhood staple, the kind of place where regulars chat in both Spanish and English. The atmosphere is relaxed whether you dine in or grab takeout, and there’s something welcoming about the familiar faces behind the counter.
It’s the flavors that make this spot memorable. Every taco is handmade and loaded with filling—no skimpy toppings here. They manage to keep things classic yet flavorful, with tortillas that taste just pressed and vibrant toppings that never overpower.
Order the Steak or Grilled Chicken Tacos. Both are tender, well-seasoned, and generously wrapped, reflecting the kind of unpretentious, satisfying Tex-Mex the restaurant does best. Each visit here is a reminder that sometimes the simplest approach delivers big rewards.
4. Holy Guacamole
Holy Guacamole stands out as a go-to inside Smith Haven Mall. The vibe is relaxed, with bright decor and quick service, perfect when you want fresh food on a busy day of errands. I’ve stopped in more than once after shopping, always impressed by the portion sizes and the striking flavor of their salsas and guacamole.
This isn’t your standard mall food. The tacos are made to order, and the fillings are generous without being overstuffed. You can taste the care in every detail, from the crisp vegetables to the warm, pillowy tortillas.
Try the Grilled Fish Tacos or the Vegetarian Tacos; both capture the kitchen’s knack for balancing zest and freshness. Each visit reminds you that quick food can still feel special, especially when the guacamole lives up to the name.
5. Chimichanga Mexican Grill
(631) 737-8080Call
Chimichanga Mexican Grill delivers a low-key dining experience where quality never takes a backseat. It’s a spot I stumbled upon one rainy afternoon, and it turned out to be just the warm, satisfying escape I needed. The staff treats regulars and newcomers alike with a friendly, no-fuss attitude.
What makes Chimichanga stand out is their approach to freshness and portion sizes. You’ll find no shortcuts here; every dish feels home-cooked, and the flavors come through in every bite.
For taco cravings, try the Grilled Veggie or Chicken Tacos. Each taco is filled with well-seasoned proteins and bright, crisp toppings, wrapped in soft tortillas. It’s a reliable choice that brings comfort with every visit, all without any unnecessary flash.
6. Senor Taco Mexican Grill
(631) 676-4011Call
Senor Taco Mexican Grill brings reliable flavors and fast service to the heart of Ronkonkoma. On my first visit, I noticed the quick turnaround on orders without sacrificing the vibrant, homemade taste that sets them apart from typical fast food spots.
Freshness and consistency are Senor Taco’s calling cards, with each taco built to order and ingredients that taste like they just left the market. The portions are hearty but never overwhelming, and the menu offers something for everyone.
For a true taste of what they do best, go for the Soft Corn Chicken or Veggie Tacos. They’re filling, balanced, and easy to customize with a range of salsa options. Each bite showcases what makes this local favorite worth revisiting.
7. Chili’s Grill & Bar
Chili’s Grill & Bar is a familiar name, but its Tex-Mex menu surprises with more than the usual comforts. I once ducked in for a quick lunch and stuck around, pulled in by the energetic buzz and friendly servers. It’s an easy place to go from a casual catch-up to dinner with friends.
The menu offers an impressive variety of tacos, each with a bold, approachable spin. Chili’s keeps things fresh and portions generous, giving you mainstream flavor without losing sight of quality.
If you’re looking for tacos, try the Grilled Chicken Tacos or the black bean-filled Veggie Tacos. Both capture that classic Chili’s flavor—tangy, seasoned, and balanced with crunchy slaw and fresh pico. It’s comfort food, tailored for serious taco cravings.
8. Taco Bell
Taco Bell is a familiar fixture for quick, crave-worthy bites that never take themselves too seriously. It’s the spot I hit when the clock says midnight and every other taco joint is long closed. The menu is a playground of options designed to satisfy any level of hunger, day or night.
Speed and affordability set Taco Bell apart, but consistency is the real secret. Whether you’re in a rush or easing into a late-night craving, the tacos arrive fresh and warm, always with reliable flavor.
If you’re focused on tacos, start with the Black Bean Soft Taco or Crunchy Potato Taco. Both offer that signature Taco Bell twist: simple, filling, and customizable to suit any taste. The sauces let you add a kick, making every visit a build-your-own adventure.
9. El Rio Restaurant
El Rio Restaurant is a Centereach staple where authentic flavors and inviting service meet. My first visit was a quiet weekday lunch, and the place still buzzed with regulars swapping recommendations and laughter over sizzling plates. There’s something warm and genuine about the space—perfect for family meals or solo stops alike.
El Rio puts emphasis on traditional recipes and fresh ingredients, mixing familiar comforts with little touches that elevate the experience. They manage to deliver the kind of robust, from-scratch taste you don’t always find in a casual setting.
If tacos are on your radar, order the Grilled Veggie or Chicken Tacos. Both showcase fresh toppings and perfectly seasoned proteins, each bite revealing the kitchen’s respect for classic Mexican cooking. Expect full flavors and a satisfying finish every time.
10. Taquerza Y Restaurant
(631) 615-2618Call
Taquerza Y Restaurant is the sort of place you find by word of mouth and quickly add to your repeat list. I stumbled in on a rainy afternoon and was greeted with a menu full of options that show a real love of Mexican comfort food. The atmosphere is straightforward, with a focus on the food rather than fuss.
This spot stands out for its blend of family recipes and deli-style convenience. Everything arrives fresh and made to order, so there’s always that satisfying feeling with every bite. The kitchen balances flavor and tradition without shortcuts.
For tacos, try the Grilled Chicken or Veggie Tacos. Both are made with care, loaded with crisp toppings and savory fillings on soft corn tortillas. If you want a down-to-earth, honest take on tacos, Taquerza Y delivers every time.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for tacos in Centereach, NY?
Top spots include Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill, El Rio Restaurant, Taco El Primo, and Moe’s Southwest Grill. Each offers fresh, customizable tacos that satisfy a range of tastes.
Are there halal-friendly taco options in Centereach?
Yes, several places highlight fresh, all-natural or vegetarian fillings, making it easy to stick to halal-friendly choices. Always check with staff about prep details.
Can I get vegetarian or vegan tacos in Centereach?
Absolutely. Most taco restaurants here offer grilled veggie tacos and bean-based options. Many also provide dairy-free toppings and classic salsas.
Which taco spot is kid-friendly?
Family-friendly options include Moe’s Southwest Grill, Chili’s Grill & Bar, and El Rio Restaurant, with simple flavors and flexible menus for little ones.
Are there gluten-free taco options near Centereach?
Many spots, such as Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill and Taco El Primo, offer tacos with corn tortillas and naturally gluten-free ingredients. Just confirm kitchen practices if you have allergies.
Is takeout or delivery available for tacos in Centereach?
Nearly every taco spot in Centereach offers takeout, and many partner with delivery apps for convenience on busy days.
