Searching for the best tacos in Garden City, NY can feel like chasing a moving food truck. One day you’re craving perfect carne asada; the next, you want fresh fish or tangy veggie fillings wrapped in a soft tortilla. With options scattered across Garden City and its nearby pockets, choosing where to start gets almost as tricky as deciding between red or green salsa.
After countless taco runs (purely for research, of course), I’ve sorted through cozy grills, lively taquerias, and no-frills counters to pin down the top spots for tacos that actually deliver flavor and freshness. Whether you’re a fan of classic chicken, bold beef, or imaginative vegetarian options, this guide will help you skip the guessing game. Let’s unravel where you can crunch, savor, and possibly find your next taco obsession—without the fuss.
Where to find the best tacos in Garden City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Garden City, NY:
- Seasons 52
- Tocolo Cantina
- Green Cactus Grill
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Poco Loco
- Guac Shop Mexican Grill
- Homemade Taqueria Hempstead
- Burrito Blvd
- Chimichurri Charcoal Chicken
- El Porton Restaurant
1. Seasons 52
Seasons 52 sits at the crossroads of fresh flavor and comfort. Walking in, you notice the menu follows the calendar—each visit brings something new. I once sampled their market-fresh tacos and was struck by how lightly grilled vegetables and lean proteins let each bite shine.
What sets Seasons 52 apart is its commitment to lighter fare, all without sacrificing taste. Their chef-led approach means every dish, including their tacos, showcases peak ingredients and thoughtful pairings.
If you’re choosing tacos, try the grilled shrimp or all-veggie versions. Both arrive with vibrant slaws and zesty sauces, perfectly reflecting the restaurant’s seasonal philosophy. For those craving freshness and quality in every taco, Seasons 52 delivers with a lighter, modern twist.
2. Tocolo Cantina
Tocolo Cantina feels both sleek and warm from the moment you step inside. Exposed copper, lively music, and that sweeping garage door set a scene where modern Mexican cuisine takes center stage. The first time I tried their tacos, a plate of vibrant fillings arrived with hand-pressed tortillas—each bite matched their reputation for refined flavor.
This spot stands out with its sophisticated spin on traditional favorites. Every dish tastes thoughtfully elevated, but still approachable. If you’re torn, try the shrimp or veggie tacos, loaded with fresh salsas and inventive toppings.
Tocolo Cantina’s tacos blend authenticity with creative flair, making them a must for anyone hungry for a memorable, elevated taco experience in Garden City.
3. Green Cactus Grill
Green Cactus Grill is the type of spot where you can walk in any day and count on quick, no-nonsense service with plenty of flavor. It’s not a flashy place, but it nails the kind of Mexican food you crave—fresh, easy to customize, and always satisfying. My first visit had me trying their grilled chicken tacos, piled high with crisp lettuce and a light, zesty salsa.
What sets Green Cactus Grill apart is their focus on healthy, straightforward options without cutting corners on taste. Their prices are reasonable, which means you can eat well without racking up a big bill. You’ll find vegetarian and vegan-friendly picks, too.
For a dependable taco, order the grilled veggie or chicken combo. Both deliver a generous helping of fresh ingredients, showing Green Cactus Grill’s commitment to simple, honest food.
4. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill offers a playful take on familiar favorites right in the heart of Garden City. Fast service, a laid-back vibe, and that signature “Welcome to Moe’s” makes every visit feel a bit like catching up with an old friend. My first taco run here ended with a tray of crispy shells filled to order, plus the bonus of free chips and salsa.
Moe’s stands out with its build-your-own setup. You can pick every ingredient, making it easy to tailor tacos to your taste or dietary needs. The fresh pico de gallo and seasonal salsas give each bite a bright, homey touch.
Try the grilled chicken or tofu tacos, which let the ingredients shine. With so many customizable choices, Moe’s lets you create a taco that’s all yours—no guesswork required.
5. Poco Loco
Poco Loco brings a bold, festive approach to Mexican dining just minutes from Garden City. Walk inside, and you’ll notice the lively vibe and the inviting mix of Latin American and Spanish flavors. When I visited, the aroma of sizzling veggies and spices drew me to order their soft corn tortilla tacos, known for generous fillings.
This spot shines for its variety and balance of flavor, with a menu built for sharing. Diners can enjoy classics, but the real highlight is how each taco bursts with fresh toppings and house-made salsas.
The grilled shrimp and veggie tacos set the standard here—both come with crisp lettuces, bright pico de gallo, and just enough heat to keep things interesting.
6. Guac Shop Mexican Grill
Guac Shop Mexican Grill is where vibrant flavors meet a modern, health-conscious spirit. From the first time I dropped in, I was struck by how friendly the staff were and how easy it was to customize my meal. Whether you’re following a special diet or just craving something bold, their menu gives you plenty of choices.
Guac Shop stands out for its flexible, build-your-own approach. Every taco bursts with your choice of fresh fillings—think grilled chicken, veggies, or plant-based proteins. Their homemade guacamole and colorful toppings turn each taco into a little celebration.
Try the chicken or plant-based tacos with a scoop of their signature guac. The flavors stay bright and fresh, making this a favorite for anyone seeking both taste and health in Garden City.
7. Homemade Taqueria Hempstead
Homemade Taqueria Hempstead is where old-school authenticity shines. You can taste the tradition in every bite, from their hand-pressed corn tortillas to the fillings cooked fresh each day. My first visit had me lingering over tacos that felt straight from a bustling Mexico City street stall—simple, flavorful, and always satisfying.
The atmosphere is relaxed and neighborly, making it just as great for a solo lunch as for a dinner with friends. Freshness is the headline here, and it shows in both the classic recipes and generous portions.
The standout order? Try their fish or veggie tacos. Each delivers bold flavor and a perfect chew, reflecting Homemade Taqueria’s promise: if it’s not homemade, it’s not the best.
8. Burrito Blvd
Burrito Blvd puts a fun, fast twist on Mexican classics just a quick drive from Garden City. It’s the kind of spot where you’re greeted with bright décor and a smell that promises you made the right lunch choice. The first time I dropped by, I tried their mix-and-match tacos—each filled to order and stacked with fresh veggies.
What makes Burrito Blvd different is the way they blend quality with speed. You never feel rushed, yet your food arrives fast enough for a quick break. Customizable tacos let you stack up flavors and textures your way, whether you like things spicy or mild.
Go for the grilled chicken or sautéed veggie tacos. Both showcase their knack for keeping things fresh and flavorful, perfect for a casual meal that doesn’t skimp on taste.
9. Chimichurri Charcoal Chicken
Chimichurri Charcoal Chicken is where smoky, slow-cooked flavor takes the lead. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of chicken roasting over charcoal sets the mood—and the menu doesn’t disappoint. I once sat near the open grill, watching the cooks baste the meat with their signature chimichurri sauce, and knew I was in for something different.
This spot is all about tender, charcoal-roasted chicken with Latin flair. Their tacos feature this star ingredient, served with fresh toppings and a kick of their tangy sauce. Every bite combines juicy meat and a hint of smoke, reflecting their unique take on traditional favorites.
Try the chicken tacos topped with fresh slaw. They’re straightforward but bursting with rich, balanced flavors, perfect for anyone who loves bold taste without any fuss.
10. El Porton Restaurant
(516) 565-1234Call
El Porton Restaurant feels like a neighborhood anchor for authentic Mexican fare in Hempstead. The space is cozy, with the kind of relaxed energy that draws both locals and newcomers. My first experience here involved a generous plate of tacos on warm corn tortillas, packed with flavorful grilled fillings and plenty of fresh garnish.
El Porton stands out for both the quality of their cooking and the welcoming service. The attention to traditional recipes and fresh ingredients is clear in every dish, making even a simple taco memorable.
Order their grilled veggie or chicken tacos, known for their perfectly seasoned fillings. Each bite captures what El Porton does best: homestyle food that feels like it was made just for you.
More Things to Try in Garden City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for tacos in Garden City, NY?
Some top spots include Tocolo Cantina, Guac Shop Mexican Grill, and Green Cactus Grill. Each offers unique flavors and fresh ingredients, so you’ll find something for every taste.
Are there vegetarian or vegan taco options in Garden City?
Absolutely. Guac Shop Mexican Grill and Green Cactus Grill have plenty of vegetarian and vegan-friendly taco fillings featuring grilled veggies, beans, and plant-based proteins.
Can I find halal or non-haram taco options in Garden City?
Several restaurants focus on chicken, veggie, and fish tacos, so there are non-haram options. Just ask your server about specific ingredients and preparation if you have dietary concerns.
Is there any place to get authentic Mexican street-style tacos?
Homemade Taqueria Hempstead and El Porton Restaurant serve classic street-style tacos with fresh corn tortillas and traditional toppings.
Are there good tacos for takeout or delivery in Garden City?
Yes. Many local favorites, like Moe’s Southwest Grill and Guac Shop Mexican Grill, offer easy takeout and delivery options for a taco night at home.
