Finding the best tacos in Holbrook, NY isn’t some wild quest for the perfect tortilla and filling. It’s more of a reward for curiosity—one reliable taco after another, tucked away in unexpected local spots and familiar joints. Holbrook’s taco scene always seems to have just one more surprise waiting. Some places serve up casual street-style tacos; others offer inventive twists without straying from classic integrity. If you’re someone who believes that true flavor is found not just in salsas, but in the spaces between sizzle and spice, you’re in good company.
Trying tacos across Holbrook has become a bit of a habit, and the results are worth every bite. Each location has its own accent: brisk, bright, or a slow-burn of flavor. Whether you’re more drawn to slow-cooked meats, vegetarian fillings, or simple grilled perfection, Holbrook serves up a lot more than average. This guide is based on real orders, real conversations at the counter, and more than one second helping. Let’s break down where you’ll find the tacos worth your time—without missing what gives each spot its own personality.
Where to find the best tacos in Holbrook, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Holbrook, NY:
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Sabrosa Mexican Grill
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
- Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc
- Chimichanga Mexican Grill
- Right Coast Taqueria
- Senor Taco Grill
- Burrito Palace & Grill
- Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
- Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar
1. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina sits right on the edge of Holbrook and delivers consistent Tex-Mex hits every visit. You can feel the energy the moment you walk in, with the aroma of freshly-made chips and salsa greeting you at the door. Their staff is quick with a recommendation, making it easy for indecisive taco hunters.
The standout here is the Grilled Chicken Tacos. Simple, yet satisfying, the chicken arrives juicy and dressed with crisp lettuce and a punchy salsa. If you like layers of flavor, the seasoned beef tacos don’t hold back either. Both choices showcase the restaurant’s commitment to fresh ingredients.
I’ve found myself returning, mostly for those tacos, but the bright, laid-back vibe is a plus. This is a solid starting place when mapping out Holbrook’s taco lineup.
2. Sabrosa Mexican Grill
Sabrosa Mexican Grill quietly claims its space in the Kohl’s Plaza, but their tacos are anything but subtle. The place stays busy for good reason—taco nights here are a neighborhood tradition. I still remember my first street taco at Sabrosa: fresh cilantro and diced onion made each bite snap with flavor.
What sets Sabrosa apart is authenticity and hearty portions. The Carne Asada Taco, in particular, speaks for itself. The meat is charred just enough to lock in the flavor without losing its tenderness. If you’re vegetarian, their black bean tacos pack a punch and never feel like an afterthought.
Sabrosa’s menu feels both genuine and approachable, making it easy to keep coming back. For a true local gem with a steady following, Sabrosa always manages to hit the right note.
3. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Taco El Primo Restaurant is a spot where you settle in, scan the Spanish and English menus, and realize you’re about to eat like a local. The hospitality is part of the charm here—I’ve had a conversation or two that lasted almost as long as my meal. It’s a place where regulars order confidently and newcomers get treated like family.
The Al Pastor Tacos are a standout, setting the bar with perfectly marinated meat and just the right amount of pineapple. Each taco is packed with flavor, never overloaded or skimpy. If you want something lighter, their fish tacos are fresh and never greasy.
Taco El Primo takes pride in honest, vibrant flavors, and it shows on every plate. A solid pick when you crave authentic tacos with a side of conversation.
4. Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc
Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc sits right on Main Street, drawing in anyone who loves their tacos with a little extra kick. The value here can’t be missed—generous portions and wallet-friendly prices keep the dining room busy. There’s a neighborhood vibe, and it’s easy to feel at home, whether you’re dining in or picking up.
Their Chicken Tinga Tacos are a must-try. The slow-cooked chicken is smoky, rich, and finished with crisp lettuce and a tangy crema. For those who want something more classic, the grilled steak tacos deliver with every bite, showing Habanero’s attention to seasoning and freshness.
Every visit leaves you satisfied, and there’s always a small surprise—sometimes it’s the daily salsa or a twist on toppings. Habanero’s brings bold Tex-Mex flavor right to the center of Holbrook.
5. Chimichanga Mexican Grill
(631) 737-8080Call
Chimichanga Mexican Grill is an easy spot to find along Portion Road, and it promises more than just a quick bite. There’s a relaxed neighborhood energy here, with friendly staff who remember what you ordered last time. My first visit turned into a conversation about homemade salsas, and I left with a new favorite taco spot.
The Grilled Shrimp Tacos are the highlight for anyone craving something fresh and a little different. The shrimp are perfectly seared and topped with a citrusy slaw that brightens up every mouthful. The steak tacos, another strong choice, balance their smoky flavor with just the right amount of sharp salsa.
Chimichanga stands out for quality and atmosphere. Each taco has balance—the kind that makes you linger just a bit longer over lunch. This place makes regulars out of anyone who walks in.
6. Right Coast Taqueria
Right Coast Taqueria captures a bit of big-city energy, tucked right into the rhythm of Ronkonkoma. The décor feels playful without trying too hard, and the staff keeps things moving with upbeat efficiency. My last trip here was one of those rare quick lunches that still felt satisfying and unhurried.
The Baja Fish Tacos are essential here. Crisp, flaky fish, bright cabbage, and just enough creamy sauce—each bite is a balance of flavor and crunch. If you’re a fan of heat, the spicy chicken tacos are just bold enough to wake up your palate without overwhelming it.
Right Coast isn’t afraid to give classics a twist, and the results are always fresh. A go-to for adventurous taco fans who want something memorable with every order.
7. Senor Taco Grill
Senor Taco Grill sits right on Patchogue Holbrook Road, and it’s the kind of place you start thinking about before you’re even hungry. The staff is friendly and quick, and the space has a comfortable, easy feel. Once, a last-minute lunch turned into a discovery of real taco variety here.
The Birria Tacos are the star of the show. Stewed beef, tender and peppery, tucked into a crispy shell with enough depth to keep each bite interesting. They serve it with consommé on the side, so you can dip the tacos and bring out even more flavor. Their veggie tacos, full of grilled peppers, stand out for color and freshness.
Senor Taco Grill feels unfussy but delivers on flavor. A great spot for anyone craving something both authentic and memorable.
8. Burrito Palace & Grill
Burrito Palace & Grill is a cozy, no-fuss spot that covers both Mexican and Mediterranean cravings. You’ll notice right away that regulars feel at home here—there’s a sense of familiarity, whether you’re calling ahead or dropping by for lunch. On a rainy afternoon, I ducked in for tacos and ended up staying far longer than planned.
The Grilled Chicken Tacos are the pick here: served fast, steaming hot, and generously filled. Every taco is loaded with grilled chicken, crisp lettuce, and a house-made salsa that tastes as if it was prepped just moments before it landed on your table. For those who like it classic yet hearty, this is the place.
It’s easy to see why Burrito Palace & Grill keeps its fans. Everything is straightforward, flavorful, and pleasantly filling.
9. Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill
(631) 580-2226Call
Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill finds a way to keep things lively, even during a quick lunch rush. Walking in, you’re greeted by a bright interior that matches the food—everything looks fresh and feels welcoming. My visits have always ended with a strong urge to try just one more taco.
The Fish Tacos are the big draw. Lightly battered and topped with crunchy slaw plus a squeeze of lime, each taco delivers freshness and flavor in equal measure. If you like a bit of heat, their grilled chicken tacos with spicy salsa never disappoint and don’t overpower the rest of the ingredients.
Cabo Fresh wins with its bold flavors and quick, cheerful service. It’s a go-to for anyone craving something vibrant and unfussy.
10. Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar
Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar brings together fast service and comfort, all in a spot that’s perfect for solo diners or groups. There’s a laid-back warmth here—one visit was enough to add it to my regular taco circuit. The energy feels local, like you’re part of the neighborhood conversation even if you’re just passing through.
The Carne Asada Tacos are a top pick. The steak is juicy, well-seasoned, and served with freshly chopped onions and cilantro. Each taco is built to let the ingredients shine without fillers or distractions. Their veggie tacos, loaded with grilled vegetables, offer plenty for those looking for a lighter but still satisfying option.
For anyone wanting reliability and quality without the wait, Señor Taco has you covered every time. It’s a spot that values flavor and speed in equal measure.
More Things to Try in Holbrook, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places to get tacos in Holbrook, NY?
Some local favorites include On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina, Sabrosa Mexican Grill, Taco El Primo Restaurant, and Senor Taco Grill. Each offers their own style, from classic street tacos to inventive variations.
Are there any vegetarian taco options in Holbrook?
Yes, many spots such as Sabrosa Mexican Grill and Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar offer vegetarian tacos packed with grilled vegetables or seasoned beans. You’ll find flavorful choices for non-meat eaters.
Can I find authentic Mexican tacos in Holbrook, NY?
Several local restaurants serve traditional versions. Look for tacos made with fresh cilantro, onions, and your choice of meats or vegetarian fillings—Sabrosa Mexican Grill and Taco El Primo Restaurant are just two to start with.
Do any taco spots in Holbrook offer delivery or takeout?
Most taco restaurants in Holbrook, including Habanero’s Tex Mex Inc and Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill, offer takeout and delivery options for easy dining at home.
Where can I get fish tacos in Holbrook?
Cabo Fresh Mexican Grill and Right Coast Taqueria both serve standout fish tacos, with fresh toppings and crispy, flavorful fish.
