There’s something oddly comforting about hunting down the best tacos in a small town like Hurley, NY. Maybe it’s the anticipation before that first bite or the way a soft corn tortilla can turn a Tuesday into a mini celebration. After more than a few taste tests and sidelong glances from curious locals, I’ve found that tacos in Hurley aren’t just food—they’re a portal into lively kitchens, inventive flavors, and quiet local pride.
If you’re searching for fresh salsa, perfectly seasoned fillings, or crave a spot that’s big on taste but low on fuss, you’ve landed in the right place. In this guide, you’ll find everything from classic taquerias to funky diners where tacos might surprise you. Each spot here has earned its spot through personal experience or solid local buzz, so you can set out with real confidence—and maybe even a bit of hunger. Let’s unravel Hurley’s taco scene, one salsa-splattered napkin at a time.
Where to find the best tacos in Hurley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Hurley, NY:
- El Jaguar Restaurant
- Alebrijes
- Sky View Mexican Restaurant
- Diego’s Taqueria
- Dietz Stadium Diner
- Santa Fe Uptown
- Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant
- Mole Mole
- Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant
- Armadillo Bar & Grill
1. El Jaguar Restaurant
El Jaguar Restaurant on Wall Street isn’t your average taco spot. What immediately stands out is their fusion of Guatemalan and Mexican flavors, creating a menu that’s both comforting and full of surprises. On my visit, the tortillas were fresh and warm, and the fillings—especially the slow-cooked chicken tinga—carried depth and balance in every bite.
The taco plate here is a must-try. Each taco arrives neatly packed and just spicy enough to wake up your taste buds without overwhelming the flavors. Don’t miss the carne asada tacos, which reveal El Jaguar’s knack for getting char and tenderness just right.
This cozy spot is immaculate, with attentive staff who genuinely seem to care. For a meal in Hurley that feels a little adventurous but always satisfying, El Jaguar delivers in spades.
2. Alebrijes
(845) 853-8388Call
Alebrijes sits quietly off Forest Hill Drive but makes a loud statement with its cleverly crafted tacos and Latin-inspired flair. The atmosphere hints at something between a family gathering and a hidden gem, and my own visit felt like stumbling onto a local secret everyone was happy to share.
Their tacos are generous and vibrant, with pillowy tortillas and fillings that burst with flavor. I’d recommend the shrimp tacos, where a squeeze of lime pulls out a bright, satisfying finish, or the vegetarian option, filled with seasoned vegetables that even meat-lovers will appreciate.
What sets Alebrijes apart is their attention to detail and the way each plate feels custom-made. If you want tacos that strike a balance between comfort and creativity, this is your place to start.
3. Sky View Mexican Restaurant
Sky View Mexican Restaurant is perched in a spot that seems made for lingering meals and easy conversation. From the first bite, you can tell their tacos are built on fresh ingredients and careful technique. I once spent a lazy afternoon here, watching the kitchen hustle while my tacos arrived steaming and fragrant.
The fish tacos are their signature move, perfectly crispy with just the right snap of cabbage and a lilt of citrus in the sauce. The grilled chicken taco is also worth a mention—plump, juicy, and not hiding behind heavy toppings.
This place stands out for its bright, feel-good flavors and genuine warmth from the staff. If you like your tacos with a view and a side of calm, Sky View fits the bill.
4. Diego’s Taqueria
Diego’s Taqueria brings a youthful pulse to John Street, delivering tacos with energy and inventiveness that are hard to miss. This spot thrives on bold flavors and unfussy presentation. My own midday stop was rewarded with a bustling counter and tacos that felt indulgent, yet light enough to keep me exploring Kingston after lunch.
The sweet potato and black bean tacos are a revelation, sweet and smoky with a hint of spice, while the grilled fish taco holds its own with freshness and a satisfying crunch. Here, you get the sense that tacos are a craft rather than a menu afterthought.
With its lively pace, friendly faces, and creative options, Diego’s Taqueria earns its keep as a go-to for taco fans in Hurley.
5. Dietz Stadium Diner
Dietz Stadium Diner isn’t just known for its comfort classics—it’s a place where the unexpected taco on the menu delights with real substance. This family-run spot bustles with locals at almost any hour, which speaks volumes for its staying power. I’m always struck by the genuine warmth as regulars banter over coffee or catch up between bites.
Their breakfast taco shines, loaded with fluffy eggs, salsa, and crisp potatoes, wrapped in a perfectly warm tortilla. There’s also a solid grilled veggie taco that doesn’t skimp on flavor or portion.
The diner’s charm comes from its all-day, any-craving menu. For those who love classic diners but want a taco twist, Dietz Stadium Diner brings a little surprise to every meal.
6. Santa Fe Uptown
Santa Fe Uptown feels like one of those places where the mood lifts as soon as you step inside. The setting is both festive and soothing, with just enough candlelight to set the right tone for good conversation and great food. On a recent visit, the cheerful buzz of regulars made it clear this spot is a local favorite.
The tacos here are anchored by fresh, all-natural ingredients. My top pick is the grilled fish tacos—zesty, flaky fish dressed in fresh slaw, all wrapped in house-made tortillas. Also worth a shout: their vegetarian tacos, which showcase both seasonal produce and clever seasoning.
Santa Fe Uptown offers both consistency and a little flair, making every meal feel like an occasion. It’s where you go for a taco night that feels impressively put together, without ever being stuffy.
7. Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant
Casa Villa Mexican Restaurant is a longtime Kingston staple, and every visit reminds me why locals keep coming back. This spot manages to blend the heartiness of Tex-Mex with Mexican classics in a way that never feels forced. I always notice how the staff switch between English and Spanish, making every guest feel at home.
The chicken tacos here are a personal favorite—juicy, perfectly seasoned, and topped with a playful crunch of cabbage. For something a bit different, their grilled fish tacos bring brightness with citrus and fresh herbs. Each plate looks as inviting as it tastes.
Casa Villa stands out for generous portions and a genuine sense of place. If you want tacos that capture both comfort and craft, this is a great bet in Hurley’s orbit.
8. Mole Mole
(845) 338-4765Call
Mole Mole feels like a cheerful detour from the usual, favoring fresh and light Mexican staples that don’t weigh you down. There’s an ease here—quick service, breezy space, and dishes built for fast satisfaction. My order arrived hot and vibrant, no fuss, just honest flavors.
The grilled chicken tacos are always a win, topped with crisp lettuce, diced onions, and a salsa that tastes like summer. For a lighter touch, their veggie tacos pair bright, sautéed vegetables with unmistakably fresh tortillas.
Mole Mole stands apart for making simple taco meals feel both healthy and crave-worthy. It’s the kind of place you’ll return to midweek or whenever a taco fix needs to fit your schedule.
9. Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant
Rosita’s Mexican Restaurant is tucked along the water at Rondout Landing, making it a spot where the view matches the food. The homemade vibe carries through every detail, from the welcoming staff to the kitchen’s evident pride in their work. On my last visit, the sizzle coming from the kitchen built up the kind of anticipation only real, freshly made food can spark.
The grilled steak tacos are a top pick here—succulent, not greasy, and paired with just the right crunch from house-made slaw. If you like a bit of a kick, the salsa verde on the side brings everything together without overpowering the dish.
Rosita’s isn’t fancy, but it’s got a warmth and consistency you’ll crave again. For no-frills, flavor-packed tacos, this is one of Hurley’s under-the-radar gems.
10. Armadillo Bar & Grill
Armadillo Bar & Grill somehow manages to make every meal feel like a special find, blending tradition with inventive twists. The place has been turning out fresh, from-scratch dishes for decades, and you can taste that care in everything from their salsa to their tortillas. I still remember sitting out on their flower-filled patio on a sunny afternoon, savoring the energy and the food.
The grilled shrimp tacos deserve attention—light, a little smoky, and nestled in soft tortillas with house-made slaw. Their vegetarian taco, packed with roasted veggies and bright toppings, is another solid pick.
Armadillo stands out for offering classic comfort alongside creative flavors, served up in a space that feels as welcoming as the food on your plate.
More Things to Try in Hurley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of tacos can I find in Hurley, NY?
You’ll discover everything from classic grilled chicken and steak tacos to vegetarian, vegan, and seafood options. Some places also offer creative fillings like sweet potato or grilled veggies.
Are there good vegetarian or vegan taco choices in Hurley?
Yes, many Hurley restaurants serve vegetarian and vegan tacos with fillings like roasted vegetables, black beans, and house-made salsas. Armadillo Bar & Grill, Alebrijes, and Mole Mole are all great spots for plant-based options.
Can I get tacos with all-natural or fresh ingredients?
Absolutely. Several spots, such as Santa Fe Uptown and Casa Villa, focus on fresh, all-natural ingredients and prepare dishes from scratch daily.
Are there takeout or delivery options for tacos in Hurley?
Most local taco places offer takeout, and some also provide delivery through apps or direct ordering. Always call ahead to check or order online for convenience.
Which Hurley taco spot is best for families or groups?
Dietz Stadium Diner and Santa Fe Uptown are both known for their friendly service and spacious seating, making them great choices for families and groups looking to enjoy tacos together.
