Taco cravings hit in strange ways. Sometimes it’s a blustery Tuesday night, and all you want is a perfectly spiced bite wrapped in a soft tortilla. I remember drifting down the streets of Lynbrook, the scent of cilantro and grilled corn wafting from hidden kitchens. Those first bites convinced me: Lynbrook isn’t just another dot on the map. It’s a destination for taco aficionados.
Finding the best tacos in Lynbrook, NY demands a little curiosity and an open mind. There’s the joy of discovering a humble joint with salsa that bites back, or the surprise of a restaurant turning out classic flavors with flair. What follows isn’t guesswork or hype—it’s the result of actual taste-testing and keen observation. If you want to cut through the noise and get straight to real flavor, you’re in the right place.
1. Green Cactus Mexican Grill
Green Cactus Mexican Grill sits just outside Lynbrook, but the short trip is worth it for anyone craving serious taco flavor. The space is unpretentious and always smells like warm tortillas, grilled veggies, and fresh pico de gallo. What makes Green Cactus stand out is a focus on simple, clean ingredients paired with traditional recipes.
During my first visit, I tried their grilled chicken and steak tacos. Each taco arrived with house-made salsa and a generous sprinkle of chopped cilantro. The portions are hearty, and the fillings remain juicy, never dry. If you’re curious, the veggie tacos—served with sautéed peppers, beans, and creamy avocado—are also a standout. For anyone eating clean or vegetarian, Green Cactus delivers without sacrificing flavor or authenticity.
2. Burrito Monster
Burrito Monster might surprise you. The name hints at size, but the real delight is freshness in every bite. It has a quick-service vibe, making it a favorite for those who want great tacos without the wait. The energy here is casual and friendly—it feels like a hidden gem just minutes from Lynbrook.
The tacos are the menu’s secret star. I often order the grilled fish or chicken tacos, each one wrapped in a pillowy-soft tortilla and stuffed with zesty pico de gallo. The toppings are generous, and the house hot sauce brings everything together with just the right punch. Vegetarians aren’t left out; the bean and rice taco packs tons of flavor, no shortcuts.
3. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill is impossible to ignore if you want something quick yet flavorful near Lynbrook. My first visit ended with a tray full of free chips and house-made salsa, which set a good tone from the start. Every visit, you get to watch your taco being made, with fresh salsas and toppings added right in front of you.
The star at Moe’s is their taco trio special. Pick soft or crunchy shells and fill them with chicken, beans, or grilled veggies. Everything tastes bright and freshly prepared. The salsas—made daily—are not just filler, they amp up the flavor. Customization is easy, so you get exactly what you want every time, whether you lean classic or want to try something new.
4. El Mariachi
(516) 536-6661Call
El Mariachi in Rockville Centre brings a touch of tradition to every table. The ambiance leans festive, but there’s a comfort here that always draws me back. It’s family-friendly, and the staff gives you that extra attention you don’t see everywhere.
The carnitas and grilled fish tacos stand out for their generous portions and authentic flavor. I remember biting into the carnitas taco—tender, perfectly seasoned, wrapped in a warm corn tortilla. The fish taco is just as memorable, with a crispy edge and tangy slaw that brings freshness to every mouthful. Pair either with their mild salsa and you’ve got a meal that’s balanced, bright, and hard to beat around Lynbrook.
5. Salsa Mexicana
Salsa Mexicana feels sleek and lively, perfect for anyone who loves their taco night with a bit more flair. On my last trip, I ducked in for a quick break from the Lynbrook bustle. The atmosphere is just upscale enough to feel special, yet still relaxed.
The signature tacos are where Salsa Mexicana really shines. The grilled shrimp taco hit the spot—succulent, seasoned, and dressed in a tangy slaw. Their vegetarian taco, packed with roasted peppers and black beans, is bright and satisfying. I’m a fan of their house salsas, served with just enough heat to liven up every bite.
For a spot that bridges classic flavor with inventive touches, Salsa Mexicana earns a return visit. The menu’s range means everyone leaves happy.
6. Birria Tacos Of Valley Stream
Birria Tacos Of Valley Stream is one of those places that grabs your attention the moment you step up. The neon signs hint at big flavors, and the aroma doesn’t disappoint. This spot focuses on birria—slow-cooked, richly seasoned, and always satisfying.
The birria tacos are the clear highlight here. Each taco is dipped in flavorful consommé before hitting your plate, the tortilla crisp at the edges, and the filling boasts deep spices. The consommé on the side makes each bite even better—perfect for dipping or just sipping.
If you want tacos that deliver a bold, hearty experience, Birria Tacos Of Valley Stream is hard to top. Each order feels crafted, not rushed, and the flavors linger long after the meal ends.
7. Cabo Mexican Restaurant
Cabo Mexican Restaurant feels like a mini getaway, with vibrant colors and the hum of good energy. I’ve dropped by for a lazy weekend lunch and found the patio perfect for unwinding. The menu manages to balance classic Mexican flavors with playful, eclectic touches.
The grilled chicken tacos here are always a reliable choice. Moist, well-seasoned chicken pairs with fresh salsa and shredded lettuce, all tucked in a soft tortilla. For something a bit different, the veggie taco—loaded with fresh vegetables—shows Cabo isn’t afraid to let produce take the spotlight. The sides, especially the rice and beans, anchor every plate just right.
For tacos with personality and a setting that feels like a celebration, Cabo is an easy pick for Lynbrook taco fans.
8. Tacos y Mas II Inc
(516) 599-5252Call
Tacos y Mas II Inc is a true neighborhood spot in Lynbrook—a place where the staff remembers your face and the menu doesn’t need frills. My first order here was a round of chicken and bean tacos, and every bite struck the right balance between comfort and freshness. This place wins you over with honest flavors and generous portions.
The grilled steak tacos are a must-try, served with heaps of diced onions and cilantro. The tortillas, slightly crisped and warm, do a great job holding up all the juicy goodness. If simplicity with quality is your thing, this spot delivers every time. Tacos y Mas II Inc knows how to keep locals coming back.
9. Puerta Mexicana Inc
(516) 344-5334Call
Puerta Mexicana Inc has a small storefront, but the flavors coming out of the kitchen make a big impact. The first time I stopped in, the staff made helpful suggestions and the pace was laid-back but attentive. This spot feels like a hidden gem in East Rockaway, drawing locals who know where to find real Mexican food.
The standout here is the grilled chicken taco—tender, well-seasoned, and topped with crisp lettuce and salsa. The tortillas are soft and pack just enough chew to keep every bite interesting. For something lighter, try their veggie taco, which overflows with fresh, sautéed vegetables. Puerta Mexicana Inc excels at giving simple tacos a home-cooked touch, making them great for a relaxed lunch or casual dinner near Lynbrook.
10. J M Super Pollo
(516) 593-0601Call
J M Super Pollo doesn’t try to charm with fancy decor. Instead, it lets the food do the talking. I found myself returning here more often than planned, drawn by the unmistakable scent of grilled chicken lingering on the street. This spot leans into simple comfort, focusing on Latin American flavor and consistency.
The chicken tacos here are all about good texture and seasoning. Each tortilla gets stuffed with juicy, marinated chicken and a handful of shredded lettuce. The flavors are straightforward but satisfying, and the house salsa brings just enough brightness. If you’re in the mood for something filling with minimal fuss, J M Super Pollo always delivers on its promise of fresh, flavorful tacos near Lynbrook.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for tacos in Lynbrook, NY?
Lynbrook and its nearby towns offer dozens of taco spots, but favorites include Green Cactus Mexican Grill, Tacos y Mas II Inc, and Salsa Mexicana for their fresh ingredients and reliable flavor.
Are there vegetarian or vegan tacos available in Lynbrook?
Yes, many local places serve vegetarian and sometimes vegan tacos. Try Green Cactus Mexican Grill for hearty veggie tacos, or Salsa Mexicana for versions packed with roasted vegetables and black beans.
Where can I find authentic Mexican-style tacos near Lynbrook?
For classic Mexican-style tacos, visit Birria Tacos Of Valley Stream or Tacos y Mas II Inc. Both focus on traditional recipes and homemade tortillas.
Is there a spot for quick, casual tacos in the area?
Burrito Monster and Moe’s Southwest Grill offer tacos for when you need something tasty in a hurry. Both allow easy customization, so you get exactly what you want, fast.
Which taco places in Lynbrook are good for families?
El Mariachi and Cabo Mexican Restaurant are welcoming and have menus suitable for all ages. Portions are generous, and the atmosphere is relaxed.
