Finding the best tacos in Manorville, NY can feel like a local rite of passage. Picture this: wind ruffling your hair while you make a sharp turn off Montauk Highway, hunger setting in, and the only thought in your mind is which taqueria has that irresistible blend of spice and flavor. That’s exactly where I found myself after a long day exploring the East End. The pursuit led me to tucked-away trucks and glowing little cantinas—each one promising a new experience, every bite building up the story.
With so many options serving up tortillas filled with slow-cooked meats, crisp veggies, and bold salsas, the journey wasn’t just about filling up, but also savoring the differences in every spot. If you’re wondering where to score tacos that taste like they’re straight out of a hidden street market, you’re in the right place. What follows isn’t just a list; it’s a tried-and-tasted collection, mapped out for anyone chasing the perfect taco south of the expressway. Dive in—you’re about to find your new favorite.
Where to find the best tacos in Manorville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Manorville, NY:
- El Sabor Del Pueblo
- El Rodeo
- Golden Jalapeños Cafe
- Taqueria Cinco De May
- Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar
- Senor Taco Grill
- Funcho’s Fajita Grill
- Taqueria Mexico
1. El Sabor Del Pueblo
Tucked just a short drive from Manorville, El Sabor Del Pueblo brings real Latin flavor to Main Street. The atmosphere feels relaxed yet vibrant, drawing in anyone craving good conversation and a satisfying plate. My last visit started with a warm greeting and the smell of slow-simmered spices from the open kitchen.
What sets them apart? Handmade tortillas arrive lightly blistered, the perfect base for their chicken or beef tacos. Each taco bursts with fresh cilantro, onion, and a squeeze of lime. Their house pico—the kind you wish they’d bottle—ties it all together with a pop of brightness.
Order the steak taco plate. The meat’s seared just right and pairs well with their perfectly balanced red salsa. It’s comfort food with genuine local character.
2. El Rodeo
(631) 909-2666Call
El Rodeo sits on Montauk Highway and draws in taco lovers looking for something a bit different. The place keeps things low-key—think classic booths, friendly staff, and an easygoing, unhurried vibe. My first time here, taco night turned into a new ritual thanks to the generous servings and flavorful fillings.
What makes El Rodeo unique? Their tacos come tucked in soft tortillas with a distinct Latin flair, often featuring unexpected seasonings and crisp veggies. The kitchen isn’t afraid to mix up the flavors, and that creativity shows.
Try their grilled chicken or veggie tacos—each one comes out hot and packed with vibrant toppings. If you’re a fan of bold, simple eats that leave you full and happy, El Rodeo delivers every time.
3. Golden Jalapeños Cafe
(631) 792-6366Call
Golden Jalapeños Cafe on Middle Country Road is the perfect mix of humble and mouthwatering. The lively, no-frills setting fits right in with its focus: honest food made with care. When I stopped by, the warm welcome made me feel like a regular, even on my first visit.
The standout? Their approach to tacos. Freshly grilled fillings nestle inside sturdy tortillas, and there’s real attention to layering flavors. Even the salsa has a bite that lingers—just enough to keep you wanting more.
If you’re looking for a suggestion, go with the beef tacos. The meat comes juicy, not greasy, paired with bright pico and crisp greens. For anyone craving authentic, affordable tacos that don’t skimp on the good stuff, this spot checks every box.
4. Taqueria Cinco De May
(631) 801-6277Call
If you haven’t heard of Taqueria Cinco De May, you’re missing out on a gem near Eastport. My first trip felt like a spontaneous detour that paid off big time. The place is no-frills, but the aroma of grilled meats draws you in fast.
The flavor here is bold and direct. Street-style tacos shine, filled with tender chicken, perfectly seasoned steak, and the right amount of chopped onion and cilantro. Each taco feels handcrafted and built for real taco fans.
Order the mixed taco platter if you can’t decide—the variety captures the kitchen’s strengths. It’s clear this spot cares less about fancy décor and more about serving up the kind of tacos that get talked about long after the last bite.
5. Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar
Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar is one of those places where good food and a cheerful vibe come together. The lively energy hits as soon as you walk in, with the promise of big flavors hanging in the air. My most recent visit was on a rainy afternoon, and the tacos here turned the day right around.
What really sets Señor Taco apart is its commitment to freshness. Every taco arrives piled high with crisp veggies, tender meat, and bold, homemade salsas. The choices are broad, but nothing feels overwhelming—a rarity these days.
If you’re looking to order, go straight for the grilled fish tacos. They’re flaky, packed with flavor, and perfectly balanced with the tang of citrus slaw. Whether you grab a quick bite or linger with friends, this spot delivers on every taco promise.
6. Senor Taco Grill
Senor Taco Grill, right along Route 25a, keeps things classic yet inviting for taco lovers in the area. The place has a friendly, upbeat feel—ideal for a casual lunch or a quick dinner stop. My last meal there started with lively salsa music and ended with a fantastic taco feast.
This spot excels at balancing speed with quality. You won’t wait long, but the tacos still come out fresh and packed with carefully chosen toppings. There’s a sense of pride in each plate that goes beyond the counter-service setup.
The shrimp tacos are the highlight here: grilled to perfection, juicy, and tucked into soft, warm tortillas. If you’re chasing satisfying flavor without any fuss, Senor Taco Grill is an easy pick.
7. Funcho’s Fajita Grill
Set on West Main Street, Funcho’s Fajita Grill brings an easygoing vibe with a splash of Southwest flair. It’s the kind of place where bright murals and upbeat music help time slow down in the best way. My trip here turned into an impromptu feast where every plate felt like a personal invite to dig in.
What makes Funcho’s stand out? It’s their creative spin on familiar favorites. The tacos have that just-right balance of texture, from tender fillings to crisp slaw and a pop of fresh salsa. Nothing ever feels too heavy or bland.
Don’t miss the grilled veggie tacos. Strips of smoky vegetables come with just enough seasoning and a side of house sauce that keeps things interesting. For flavor-packed tacos with a local twist, Funcho’s hits the mark every time.
8. Taqueria Mexico
(631) 208-2902Call
Taqueria Mexico on East Main Street is a go-to for anyone who craves honest, fuss-free tacos. Its modest exterior hides a kitchen where flavors are never shy and every visit feels like a find. I remember my first time leaning against the counter, taco in hand, and realizing I’d stumbled onto a local favorite.
This spot keeps things simple—no bells, no whistles—just quality ingredients and generous portions. Each taco comes wrapped in a soft tortilla with flavorful fillings that taste homemade. The service is quick, but nothing feels rushed or overlooked.
The chicken tacos stand out here. They’re juicy, topped with just enough fresh salsa and a sprinkle of cilantro for kick. Taqueria Mexico is where affordability meets real-deal flavor every day.
More Things to Try in Manorville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for tacos in Manorville, NY?
There’s no shortage of tasty options. Local favorites include El Sabor Del Pueblo, El Rodeo, Golden Jalapeños Cafe, and Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar. Each brings something unique to the table, whether it’s homemade tortillas or creative fillings.
Are there vegetarian taco options in Manorville?
Yes, several spots like Funcho’s Fajita Grill and Golden Jalapeños Cafe offer flavorful vegetarian tacos. Look for roasted veggie or bean-based versions for plenty of taste without meat.
Can I find gluten-free tacos in Manorville?
Many places serve their tacos on corn tortillas, which are naturally gluten-free. Señor Taco Mexican Grill & Bar even has a dedicated gluten-free menu, so you have options if you’re avoiding gluten.
Is takeout or delivery available for tacos?
Most taco spots in and around Manorville, including El Sabor Del Pueblo and Moe’s Southwest Grill, offer takeout. Some restaurants partner with local delivery services too. It’s best to check the spot’s website or call ahead for details.
What should I try if I want something authentic?
Look for street-style tacos with classic fillings like grilled chicken, steak, or fish—often served with chopped onion, cilantro, and a fresh squeeze of lime. These simple, flavorful options are always a safe bet for true taco lovers.
