Medford, NY has a way of surprising you—especially if you happen to crave a good taco. You’d think a small town might play it safe with flavor, but the taco scene here is anything but plain. Over the years, I’ve zigzagged across Medford sampling tortilla creations ranging from smoky grilled chicken to roasted veggie classics. Each spot brings its own personality to the table, but one thing links them all: a genuine pride in their craft.
If you’re tired of bland wraps and want a taco that makes you pause mid-bite, you’ve come to the right guide. Across Medford’s bustling main roads and hidden side streets, there’s a spot for every craving and comfort zone—cozy mom-and-pop counters, lively chains, and even a few wild cards. Let’s pull back the foil and take a real look at the very best tacos Medford has to offer. You’ll probably find a new favorite before you’re done reading.
Where to find the best tacos in Medford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Medford, NY:
- Cactus Cafe
- Mexican Grill
- Taco Bell
- On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
- Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
- Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Taco El Primo Restaurant
- Senor Taco Grill
1. Cactus Cafe
Cactus Cafe sets the tone for tacos in Medford with its laid-back vibe and warm service. The first time I walked in, the aroma of smoked meats signaled something special happening behind the kitchen doors. What’s rare here is their dedication to in-house smoking, which gives the chicken and steak tacos a deeply satisfying flavor.
Vegetarian or vegan? You’re not sidelined—try their roasted veggie taco with zesty salsa. Every order comes out looking fresh, not fussy, with a noticeable attention to detail. The prices are kind, so it’s easy to sample a few different varieties.
If you’re unsure, start with their classic smoked chicken taco. It’s tender, vibrant, and unmistakably Cactus Cafe.
2. Mexican Grill
Mexican Grill sits just beyond Medford’s border, but locals know it’s worth the short drive. The place feels relaxed yet bustling, with the scent of cilantro and grilled vegetables pulling you right in. My first visit was on a whim, but their signature tacos made me a repeat customer.
What stood out most? Each taco is built to highlight street food roots—simple, generous, and never overdone. The tortillas arrive warm, filled with vibrant sautéed peppers or mildly spiced beef. Portions are hearty, yet the flavors never lose their balance.
For a true taste of their kitchen, order the fish tacos—lightly breaded, crisp, and topped with tangy slaw. Mexican Grill keeps things classic and absolutely satisfying.
3. Taco Bell
Taco Bell is the go-to for a late-night taco fix or a quick midday bite in Farmingville, just minutes from Medford. There’s something about the scent of spiced tortillas in the air that signals comfort food at its most reliable. On busy days, their efficient service has saved me more than once, turning hunger into satisfaction within minutes.
Taco Bell stands out for sheer variety and speed. From crunchy corn shells to soft warm tortillas, the classic Taco Supreme gets it right every time—never too heavy, always flavorful. The menu also caters to vegetarians, with options that actually stand up to the originals.
When in doubt, go for the Crunchy Taco or the Fresco Soft Taco. Both are simple, familiar, and deliver that signature Taco Bell flavor, every visit.
4. On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina
On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina in Holtsville blends the buzz of a vibrant cantina with reliable Tex-Mex classics. The sound of sizzling coming from the open kitchen sets an inviting tone, and each table instantly gets a basket of fresh chips and salsa—always a strong start in my book. It’s the kind of place where families gather, but solo diners never feel out of place.
This spot stands out for its consistency and generous portions. I’ve found the steak street tacos to be especially memorable. They arrive hot, wrapped in soft corn tortillas with a zesty cilantro-lime slaw for brightness. Vegetarian guests can opt for seasoned veggie tacos, never an afterthought here.
If you love your tacos with a build-your-own twist, order the taco trio platter, where you can mix and match cheerful combinations for a meal that’s as playful as it is satisfying.
5. Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille
Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille in Selden is a true local gem for those who crave authentic tacos. The cozy, no-frills spot gives you that home-cooked comfort, and the staff always greet you with genuine enthusiasm. I wandered in for lunch one rainy afternoon, and their food instantly warmed things up.
What sets Blue Tortilla apart is the freshness of every bite. Tortillas are soft and earthy, pressed daily, and the fillings never feel mass-produced. The grilled shrimp taco left a lasting impression—juicy, seasoned just right, and paired with a squeeze of lime.
For a classic experience, try the chicken tinga taco. It’s rich, bright, and balanced, showing off the kitchen’s attention to both tradition and flavor.
6. Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant
Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant in Selden is a lively spot that locals mention with a smile. The walls are splashed with color and the atmosphere is always upbeat—if you ask me, it’s the kind of place that can turn any day around. My first visit here was for a quick bite, but I ended up lingering simply because the food was that good.
Viva Juan stands out for its generous portions and comforting flavors. Their veggie tacos deserve a special nod, packed with fresh vegetables and just the right level of spice. Everything feels made-to-order, not rushed or forgotten in a busy kitchen.
If you love something classic, the grilled chicken tacos are both juicy and satisfying—a great introduction to Viva Juan’s homestyle approach to Mexican food.
7. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill in Selden is one of those easygoing spots where you build your meal just the way you want. Walk in and you’re greeted by lively energy and the promise of a free basket of chips and salsa—never a bad way to start. The open kitchen lets you watch as every taco gets filled to order, which adds to the laid-back experience.
Customization is what sets Moe’s apart. Choose your favorite fillings, whether it’s tender shredded chicken, seasoned tofu, or a vibrant pile of grilled veggies. Every taco feels like it was made with you in mind.
Try the “Three Tacos” combo: pick any combination and pile on the fresh pico, crisp lettuce, or zippy salsas. For a personalized taco fix, Moe’s keeps it fun and flavorful.
8. Taco El Primo Restaurant
Taco El Primo Restaurant in Lake Ronkonkoma delivers a no-nonsense, authentic taco experience for locals in the know. The staff here treat everyone like family, whether you’re fluent in Spanish, English, or both. My first meal at El Primo was a quiet weekday lunch; within two bites, I knew I’d found the real deal.
What sets Taco El Primo apart is uncompromising freshness and an inviting homey feel. Tacos come straight from the kitchen, stuffed with your choice of grilled steak or spiced chicken, never skimping on the flavor.
Order the chicken tacos with a side of salsa verde for a well-balanced, memorable meal. The flavors here are simple, honest, and a clear reflection of El Primo’s roots.
9. Senor Taco Grill
Senor Taco Grill in Holbrook doesn’t try to be flashy—its strength is in the food. The first time I stopped in was after a rough day, and their warm welcome plus a plate piled high with tacos turned my mood around right away. The setting is casual yet cheerful, ideal for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with friends.
This spot stands out for its bold flavors and reliable freshness. Each taco arrives brimming with fillings, whether it’s grilled chicken, sautéed veggies, or perfectly seasoned beef, all tucked into soft, pliable tortillas.
Don’t miss the grilled chicken tacos with their smoky flair, or if you’re feeling adventurous, sample the veggie tacos with house-made salsa. Senor Taco Grill brings big flavor without losing the inviting, local feel.
More Things to Try in Medford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best taco spots in Medford, NY?
Top picks include Cactus Cafe, Blue Tortilla Fresh Mexican Grille, and Taco El Primo Restaurant. Each of these offers standout tacos with quality ingredients and lots of flavor.
Are there vegetarian or vegan taco options in Medford?
Yes, places like Cactus Cafe, Moe’s Southwest Grill, and Viva Juan Mexican Restaurant serve excellent vegetarian and even vegan tacos packed with fresh veggies and plant-based proteins.
Can I find authentic Mexican tacos in Medford?
For authentic options, head to local favorites like Blue Tortilla or Taco El Primo, where the focus is on traditional recipes, homemade tortillas, and genuine flavors.
Which taco spots offer takeout or delivery in Medford?
Most places do, including Taco Bell, Moe’s Southwest Grill, and On The Border Mexican Grill & Cantina. Check each restaurant’s website or call ahead for details on delivery.
Where can I get the best value tacos in Medford?
For generous portions without breaking the bank, try Mexican Grill or Senor Taco Grill. These spots are known for fair prices and quality ingredients.
