Hunting for the best tacos in Rye, NY can feel like a little adventure—one full of choices, surprises, and the occasional napkin emergency. Rye might be a small town, but its taco scene makes a bigger statement than you’d expect. After too many taste tests to count, I’ve discovered that every spot on this list brings its own twist, whether you’re after classic carne asada, inventive veggie fillings, or something with a little seaside flair. Each place holds a story, both on the plate and in the room.
My first taco in Rye wasn’t love at first sight—it was the second bite that won me over. Maybe it was the seared edges, maybe the tang of fresh salsa, or maybe the sound of friends debating their favorites at the next table. If you’ve ever sidestepped crowded pizza spots to seek out something wrapped in a warm tortilla, you already know the thrill. This guide will take you through the must-visit taco spots in Rye, from casual counters to sit-down spots perfect for lingering. Prepare to find your new go-to taco, whether you’re a purist or an adventurer.
Where to find the best tacos in Rye, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in Rye, NY:
- Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant
- El Tio
- Taqueria Mexicana
- Incazteca
- Taco Temptation
- Rinconcito Salvadoreno
- Ta Queria La Picardia
- Texan Chile Grill
- Salsa Picante
- Sam’s Bar and Grill P.C.N.Y.
1. Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant
Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant serves up some of Rye’s most scenic tacos, with tables perched right by the water. On a sunny afternoon, there’s nothing quite like watching sailboats drift by as you savor each bite. The open-air seating brings a coastal vibe you won’t find elsewhere in town.
What sets this spot apart isn’t just the location, but how fresh every plate tastes. The fish tacos here shine. Their crunch, paired with tangy slaw and a zingy house sauce, makes for a taco worth remembering. You can really sense the pier influence.
If you want a recommendation, go for the grilled fish tacos. They sum up Tiki Beach’s spirit—bright, fresh, and focused on quality with every bite.
2. El Tio
(914) 939-1494Call
El Tio stands as a staple for anyone craving comfort Mexican fare near Rye. There’s a casual charm to the place—family photos, lively chatter, and the scent of grilled spices. Every visit feels like joining a local tradition that everyone knows about but never grows old.
This spot is all about flavor-packed tacos. Their grilled chicken tacos balance juicy meat with house-made salsa, tucked in warm corn tortillas. The seasoning is spot on—never overpowering, always satisfying.
Personally, I’m drawn in by the friendly faces and fast service. Grab the carne asada tacos if you want to taste why regulars keep coming back. They’re proof that the simplest recipes can be the most memorable here.
3. Taqueria Mexicana
(914) 305-6525Call
Taqueria Mexicana packs big flavors into a small, no-frills space where the focus stays on the food. Its charm lies in the bustle—the steady stream of regulars, sights of fresh tortillas being prepped, and aromas wafting from the open kitchen. This spot is where I fell for the heartiness of a well-constructed taco, without a hint of pretense.
Every taco here feels homemade, from the first warm bite to the last splash of salsa. The menu leans classic, but there’s something special about their al pastor tacos. The meat, marinated just right, has a gentle kick and pairs beautifully with fresh pineapple and chopped onions.
If you’re seeking authenticity, start here. The al pastor and veggie tacos are both standout picks, showing just how satisfying simple can be.
4. Incazteca
Incazteca brings a fusion of Peruvian and Mexican flavors to the heart of Port Chester, and it’s hard not to feel the dual heritage from the first glance at the menu. The restaurant feels warm and lively, striking a rare balance between inventive cuisine and comforting classics. Each plate reflects careful thought from a kitchen proud of its roots.
What pulled me back here was the inventive twist on traditional tacos. The grilled shrimp tacos are a standout, packed with bright citrus, crisp slaw, and their signature homemade sauces. There’s a freshness and a pop of flavor that sets these tacos apart from any I’ve had elsewhere in Rye.
If you’re looking to try something that feels both familiar and exciting, these tacos deliver the best of both worlds.
5. Taco Temptation
(914) 939-0507Call
Taco Temptation is the kind of spot that invites you to settle in and expect the unexpected. The dining room is always buzzing—never too loud, but never dull. My first trip there was on a rainy afternoon, and somehow their food made the day feel warmer.
What sets Taco Temptation apart is how generously they fill their tacos. Every bite is hearty and satisfying, with tortillas that manage to hold their own. The grilled veggie tacos are the real surprise. Fresh, colorful peppers and squash get just enough char to bring out a rich, smoky flavor, balanced with a zesty pico de gallo.
Start with their veggie or chicken tacos if you want to get a true sense of their vibrant style. Let your curiosity be your guide—here, it always pays off.
6. Rinconcito Salvadoreno
Rinconcito Salvadoreno offers a cozy escape from the bustle, blending Mexican and Salvadoran flavors in a way that feels both new and nostalgic. The decor is simple and cheerful, dotted with bright tablecloths and local art. Each visit here feels like sitting in on a family gathering, and I always end up staying longer than planned.
The tacos truly stand out thanks to their homemade tortillas and generous fillings. Their chicken tacos shine—a perfect mix of well-seasoned meat, crisp cilantro, and a bright squeeze of lime. There’s something about the balance of spice and freshness that keeps me coming back.
Order a side of their house salsa to kick things up a notch. It’s the kind of place where every bite transports you somewhere vibrant, even on a quiet afternoon.
7. Ta Queria La Picardia
Ta Queria La Picardia brings a playful energy to Port Chester’s taco scene. Step inside and you’ll spot bursts of color and a welcoming staff ready to chat about their favorites. I remember stumbling in after a long day, craving something bold, and leaving with a new go-to spot.
The main draw here is their creativity. Every taco has a unique twist, but the grilled shrimp tacos deserve extra attention. Perfectly cooked shrimp meet a lively slaw and house-crafted salsa for a combination that’s both fresh and filling.
If you appreciate inventive flavors and generous portions, you’ll love it here. Be sure to ask about daily specials; sometimes, you’ll find tacos you won’t see on any other menu in town.
8. Texan Chile Grill
(914) 305-4545Call
Texan Chile Grill draws you in with the aroma of spices and a laid-back atmosphere where everyone seems comfortable. During my last visit, a rainy day, the place was full of regulars who knew exactly what they wanted. It’s the kind of spot you return to when you want something reliable—and maybe a little surprising.
The tacos here are hearty, with fillings that don’t skimp. The standout is the grilled steak taco, wrapped in a warm tortilla and topped with fresh salsa and a dash of lime. The steak is smoky, juicy, and every bite has real depth.
If you’re craving something classic but crave a bit of flair, Texan Chile Grill delivers. Their tacos blend Tex-Mex heartiness with Mexican flavor in every bite.
9. Salsa Picante
Salsa Picante brings lively energy and authentic Mexican flavors to the heart of Port Chester. The space pulses with color, conversation, and scents that draw you in from the street. On my first visit, friends and I spent almost as much time sampling salsas as we did eating the main event.
Their tacos stand out for freshness and presentation. The grilled chicken tacos come loaded with juicy chicken, crisp lettuce, and house-made salsa for that perfect balance of flavor and texture. Each bite feels bright and satisfying, with just enough heat to keep things interesting.
If you love classic flavor with a little extra punch, start here. And don’t skip the homemade chips and salsa—they’re almost as addictive as the tacos themselves.
10. Sam’s Bar and Grill P.C.N.Y.
Sam’s Bar and Grill P.C.N.Y. is the kind of place where you’ll relax the moment you step inside. The airy space, friendly staff, and a laid-back buzz make it feel like your local haunt—whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth. I came here on a whim once and left planning my next meal before I’d even finished.
Though known for grill classics, their fish tacos deserve special mention. Lightly seasoned fish, crunchy slaw, and a drizzle of creamy sauce come together in a soft tortilla. It’s simple comfort, coastal style.
If you enjoy tacos in a setting where conversation flows and every plate hits the spot, Sam’s delivers. Don’t be surprised if you linger longer than planned.
More Things to Try in Rye, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for tacos in Rye, NY?
Some top choices include Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant for waterside bites, Taqueria Mexicana for classic style, and Salsa Picante for bold flavors. Nearby Port Chester also offers excellent options.
Are there vegetarian taco options in Rye?
Yes, many spots offer delicious vegetarian tacos. Taco Temptation, Taqueria Mexicana, and Incazteca all have standout options with grilled veggies or unique plant-based fillings.
Where can I find authentic Mexican tacos?
Taqueria Mexicana and Rinconcito Salvadoreno both focus on authentic recipes and fresh, homemade tortillas. Their menus stay true to traditional flavors.
Do any taco spots in Rye offer outdoor seating?
Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant is known for its waterfront outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying tacos with a view.
Which places have the best seafood tacos?
Both Tiki Beach Pier Restaurant and Sam’s Bar and Grill P.C.N.Y. offer fresh, flavorful fish tacos that showcase local seafood with creative touches.
