Taco cravings have a way of sneaking up on you, usually right when you think you’ve got dinner sorted out. That’s exactly what happened to me during a late-afternoon wander in West Islip. With taco spots sprinkling the streets and the scent of smoky grilled meat trailing on the breeze, curiosity led me on a mission: to discover which taco truly deserves its spot at the top. After many crunchy bites and lots of napkins, a real appreciation grew—not just for great fillings, but for all the layers of flavor that make the perfect taco experience.
West Islip offers more than standard taco joints; it hides remarkable flavor in plain sight. This guide isn’t just about who sells tacos. It’s about where you’ll find tortillas that crackle, salsas that wake up your taste buds, and kitchens that take pride in serving up haram-free eats. If you want to skip frozen wraps and soggy fillings, you’re in the right place. Stick around and discover the spots where every taco tells a story, and maybe you’ll find your new repeat order, too.
Where to find the best tacos in West Islip, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best tacos in West Islip, NY:
- Besito Mexican Restaurant – West Islip Ny
- Salsa Pica Mexican Grill
- Green Cactus Mexican Grill
- Swell Taco
- Del Fuego
- Laredo Taco Company
- Bang Bang Burritos
- Mamey Mexican Taqueria
- Moe’s Southwest Grill
- Don Ricardo’s Restaurant
1. Besito Mexican Restaurant – West Islip Ny
Besito Mexican Restaurant in West Islip manages to balance upscale style with genuine warmth—a rare mix for a taco spot. From the moment you step in, the aroma of fresh tortillas and zesty salsas sets the tone for what’s ahead.
I found the tables bustling with families and couples, all savoring the menu’s wide range of options. The tacos here feel special: soft, house-made tortillas cradle tender grilled chicken or juicy shrimp. Each bite bursts with lime, cilantro, and just the right hint of spice.
Besito stands out for its attention to detail. The pollo tacos, in particular, struck the perfect balance between smoky flavor and citrusy freshness. Even better, vegetarians have delicious choices too. Try the mushroom and roasted corn taco for something hearty and vibrant.
Great for groups or a casual date night, this spot makes every taco a little event of its own.
2. Salsa Pica Mexican Grill
(631) 620-3123Call
Salsa Pica Mexican Grill sits comfortably at the intersection of friendly service and bright, bold flavors. Walking in, you’re greeted by a colorful interior and the homey sizzle of the kitchen—not to mention a staff that always seems happy to see you.
On my last visit, the menu made it difficult to pick just one taco. The grilled chicken tacos are a crowd favorite, but for something extra, the fish tacos deliver a crisp, fresh finish that lingers. Their homemade salsas, available in a surprising range of heats, let you dial up the flavor just the way you like it.
Salsa Pica stands out for its attention to fresh ingredients. No shortcuts here—the tortillas are warm, fillings vibrant, and nothing tastes store-bought. Vegetarian tacos, loaded with grilled veggies and black beans, deserve just as much love.
This is the spot when you want quick, honest tacos that never feel rushed or ordinary.
3. Green Cactus Mexican Grill
Green Cactus Mexican Grill makes taco night an easy choice, no matter your craving. Bright walls and an efficient counter setup signal you’re in a spot built for both speed and flavor. On my recent lunch break, I watched regulars come and go, each with a smile and a bag of deliciousness in hand.
The grilled shrimp tacos leave a strong impression—fresh, zesty, and loaded with crunchy slaw. For vegetarians, the grilled veggie tacos are satisfying and never an afterthought, with marinated peppers and onions tucked into soft, warm tortillas. Everything here, down to the pico de gallo, tastes like it was chopped just moments ago.
Portions are generous without being wasteful. Pricing stays refreshingly reasonable, so you can order extra guacamole without second-guessing your budget. If you want no-fuss tacos that deliver every time, Green Cactus rises to the occasion.
This is the spot for casual meals, lunch with friends, or a quick weeknight fix that never skimps on freshness.
4. Swell Taco
Swell Taco feels like a West Coast breeze slipped right into Babylon. The restaurant’s vibe is as welcoming as a beach party, and every visit feels like stepping into a laid-back gathering with friends. Flip-flops or formal shoes, everyone gets the same friendly smile at the door.
What really caught my attention was the array of tacos, each one given its own twist. The grilled fish tacos come topped with crisp cabbage and a fresh squeeze of lime. If you go veggie, their black bean taco earns its place with a bold, smoky seasoning and plenty of salsa.
Swell Taco stands out with its relaxed family-style atmosphere and a knack for flavor harmony. The tortillas are warm and soft, and every ingredient tastes hand-prepped and handled with care.
If you like your tacos with a side of good music and good conversation, this spot never disappoints.
5. Del Fuego
Del Fuego brings a bright, energetic slice of Tex-Mex right to the heart of Babylon. The first thing you’ll notice is the lively décor—local artwork fills the space and the open kitchen buzzes with activity. Every meal here feels like a celebration, with friendly staff and tables always filled with laughter.
I came in for lunch and found the menu packed with tempting choices. The standout is their grilled shrimp taco: perfectly smoky, with a cool cabbage slaw and house-made salsa that wakes up your palate. Those who want to skip seafood should try the roasted veggie taco—rich, colorful, and full of south-of-the-border flair.
Del Fuego stands apart for its commitment to fresh, local ingredients. Flavors come alive, and the homemade tortillas are a clear step above average. For a cozy dinner or lively group night, this spot keeps things satisfying and fun without ever feeling pretentious.
Between the vibrant atmosphere and knockout tacos, each visit makes it easy to see why Del Fuego has built a loyal following.
6. Laredo Taco Company
Laredo Taco Company has mastered the art of classic, comforting tacos that hit the spot any time of day. The aroma of freshly-made tortillas greets you at the door, and the open kitchen lets you watch as each order gets built from scratch. No frills, just honest, well-crafted food.
My go-to is the grilled chicken taco—tender, juicy, and wrapped in a soft, warm tortilla that makes all the difference. Their breakfast tacos are a hidden gem, stacked with fluffy eggs, potatoes, and a kick of house salsa. They serve up a variety of fresh salsas right at the counter, so you’re free to experiment with every bite.
Laredo stands out for its speed and its commitment to fresh, hand-prepared ingredients throughout the menu. Portions are generous, and prices are wallet-friendly enough to bring friends or feed the whole family.
If you want tacos made with skill and care, Laredo Taco Company delivers every time without stretching your budget thin.
7. Bang Bang Burritos
Bang Bang Burritos offers a bold twist on the usual taco stop. Step inside and you’ll find a menu that’s playful and unexpected, with creative spins on classic favorites. The energy here is contagious, and everything from the toppings bar to the music keeps things fun.
One afternoon, I went straight for their grilled veggie tacos. The flavor was huge, thanks to a lively blend of roasted peppers, onions, and signature sauces—each bite had just the right balance of crunch and heat. If you’re feeling adventurous, swap your usual fillings for their zesty chipotle potato or mango salsa tacos.
Bang Bang stands out for its willingness to experiment and its devotion to freshness. The portions are hearty and you never feel like you’re getting cookie-cutter food. Grab extra napkins: you’ll need them for these saucy, generously stuffed tacos.
This is the place for when you want to shake up your routine and try tacos done differently.
8. Mamey Mexican Taqueria
Mamey Mexican Taqueria is one of those rare spots where every detail seems right, from the colorful décor to the hearty, fresh menu. The space feels like a genuine neighborhood hangout—relaxed but buzzing with regulars who know their favorites by heart.
What really pulled me in was their attention to traditional flavors. The grilled fish tacos are crisp, vibrant, and topped with tangy slaw, striking the perfect balance between crunch and zest. I also enjoyed the sweet potato taco, which surprised me with its smoky seasoning and avocado crema.
Mamey stands out for its freshness and no-nonsense approach to flavor. Each taco is built to order, with ingredients that taste as if they just came from the morning market.
If you’re searching for tacos that feel both familiar and inventive, Mamey Mexican Taqueria is a solid bet for your next craving.
9. Moe’s Southwest Grill
Moe’s Southwest Grill is where you go when you want a crowd-pleaser for taco night or a quick bite that’s always fresh. The first thing you’ll notice here is the energy—staff is upbeat, and the line moves fast, even during a lunch rush.
I went for their build-your-own tacos, which lets you customize every layer, from seasoned rice to crisp lettuce and their variety of tasty salsas. The grilled tofu taco is surprisingly good, giving vegetarians more than the usual afterthought options. If you prefer something classic, the grilled chicken taco is always reliable and loaded up just how you like it.
Moe’s stands out for its flexibility and focus on fresh, made-to-order tacos. You get all the toppings you could want, at no extra charge, and everything tastes vibrant and made for the moment.
For quick service and tacos that taste just the way you want them, Moe’s delivers, no compromise.
10. Don Ricardo’s Restaurant
Don Ricardo’s Restaurant feels like a cozy hug from the moment you step through the door. It’s a family-style spot where laughter echoes and conversations linger, making it perfect for group dinners and relaxed nights out. The décor is classic, inviting, and refreshingly unpretentious.
The taco selection here is a true highlight. The grilled snapper taco offers a fresh, flaky bite with a kick of lime—easily a menu favorite. If seafood isn’t your thing, the grilled vegetable taco is bright and well-seasoned, with plenty of heartiness in every bite.
Don Ricardo’s stands apart through its mix of European and Latin flavors, bringing something unique to every plate. Ingredients are always fresh, and there’s a clear touch of home-kitchen care in the cooking.
For those who want a break from the usual fast-casual scene, this restaurant delivers a memorable meal worth sitting down for.
More Things to Try in West Islip, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of tacos can I find in West Islip, NY?
You’ll find everything from classic grilled chicken and beef tacos to creative options like grilled fish, shrimp, and vegetarian tacos loaded with fresh veggies and beans. Many places offer build-your-own taco bars for complete customization.
Are there halal or vegetarian-friendly taco options?
Yes, several taco spots feature vegetarian choices and can accommodate halal preferences by offering plant-based or seafood fillings. Always ask about preparation if you have special dietary needs.
Where can I get tacos late at night?
National chains and some local taquerias stay open late, especially on weekends. Moe’s Southwest Grill and Taco Bell often serve past traditional dinner hours.
Which places offer the freshest ingredients?
Locals rave about the freshness at places like Besito Mexican Restaurant, Green Cactus Mexican Grill, and Mamey Mexican Taqueria. These restaurants emphasize hand-prepared ingredients and made-to-order tacos.
Can I get tacos delivered in West Islip?
Absolutely. Most major taco restaurants and chains now offer delivery through apps, or directly from their websites and phones. Delivery usually covers West Islip and nearby areas.
